Comments for TVGuide Calls "Dick in a Box" The Funniest Video Online

TVGuide Calls "Dick in a Box" The Funniest Video Online

2007-11-26T19:15:49Z

While real TV in the US struggles over how much of a cut traditional, professional content writers ought to get from online and new media revenue - the venerable TVGuide announced today the winners of its inaugural Online Video Awards. The funniest video online according to the judges there? SNL's Dick in a Box. Originally aired in December 2006, the video is apparently believed to be funnier than any of the countless shorts posted online over the last 11 months. It is very funny.

The awards were based on 1.75 million votes, and the judgment of TVGuide editors. Awards were given in 18 categories, from Funniest Web Video (D.in a B.) to Best Original Web Drama Series ("Sanctuary"). The full list is available in the press release and the videos can be viewed through a pageload-heavy viewer on the TVGuide site. TVGuide uses the full text of the name Dick in a Box throughout the site and press release, but serves up a censored version of the actual video itself.

How is Old Media Adjusting?

There doesn't appear to be a wide variety of sources from which nominees were selected. The vast majority of the nominees come from big, traditional media or other major establishment players online. The headline winners were all mainstream TV hits already. That isn't without exception, and perhaps I'm just bitter about the fact that CBS's Clark and Michael beat out the creative genius of Chad Vader. So far, at least, I haven't found Clark and Michael funny at all.

EpicFu: This Episode With 2 Million+ YouTube Views - but No TVGuide Love

FunnyOrDie.com, Will Ferrel's site backed by GooTube investors Sequoia Capital, was named the best comedy site. Most people I've talked to say that entire site has been a vastly overpriced, one-hit wonder.

Online video reporter Liz Gannes puts it more plainly when she writes that "there‚Äôs not a little guy in sight." Gannes points out the more independent minded online video awards at the forthcoming Winnies.

It would be reactionary, of course, to say that all made-for-TV TV is bad TV and TV made for the web is good TV. There are plenty of quality cross-overs, but the TVGuide awards seem to overstate the case and be short on discovery of new content in the new medium.

Truth be told, there's a whole world of new online video sources and pundits out there. TVGuide has a huge brand and is obviously driving some traffic online already - but I'll take Digg video and Stumble Upon Video instead any day.

TVGuide, you're going to have to do better than this.

Comment from chris Jangelov on 2007-11-26

2007-11-26T23:57:51Z

I just want to tell you that "online video" seems to be more like "someline video". I just get a sign that says that this clip is not available from my location (Sweden), and, "Please pick another one". Interesting recommendation for those who want to see the winner. Maybe it's not that important after all...

Comment from Steve Woolf on 2007-11-26

2007-11-27T00:14:02Z

Thanks for including our video in your article, Marshall. Even though some of the little guys have gotten love elsewhere, it was surprising (and also not surprising) that TV Guide stuck to mostly studio-based shows. A little over a year ago we were talking to TV Guide about helping them understand online video and rolling out a show that brings the focus to move indie content creators, but I guess that notion got canned.

Comment from Marshall Kirkpatrick on 2007-11-26

2007-11-27T00:47:01Z

Thanks for letting us know about the non-display internationally, Chris. You know what so many of these big guys think: media is for people in the US only as they are the only ones worth advertising to.

Steve, that's real interesting - thanks for letting us know here that you had talked to them. Great job on the show, by the way. Hope it's working out well for you.

Comment from Martin on 2007-11-27

2007-11-27T08:37:38Z

Hmm... Dick in a Box is not availabe in Germany...