Comments for Google's Android: How Will it Compare to iPhone?

Google's Android: How Will it Compare to iPhone?

2008-05-29T21:38:42Z

RWW network blog last100 has coverage of the latest Android news coming from Google's I/O conference. Dan Langendorf writes that "as you would expect from the company that brings you search and Google Maps, Android handles information delivery, location and navigation extremely well -- or so we think. There's still no actual Android phones to play with." The obvious question on peoples lips though is: how will Android compare to Apple's iPhone? On that question there are mixed opinions.

]]> We already know that Google is preparing a lot of iPhone apps. But according to Vic Gundotra, Google's engineering vice president, Android does not represent Google's countermove against the iPhone:

"I wouldn't say that at all. I think the iPhone is just a world-class device with a great Web browser that delivers in many respects on one of Google's key goals: to bring the Web to the mobile device. We wish every mobile device was as good as the iPhone."

Some people think the comparison to the iPhone is unfair. Noted Jawad Shuaib in the last100 comments:

"The comparison between Android and the iPhone is unfair. The iPhone, with all its glorious UI experience, is a very closed and tightly controlled platform. The promise of Android is not a better user experience but rather an open experience - the sort of stuff that the mobile web really requires at this stage."

And open is where Google is headed, or at least that is their stated goal.

However Google won't be able to avoid comparisons with the iPhone that easily. Apple really did take the Mobile Web up another notch with its superb user experience and ability to run web apps in the Safari browser, due to Apple using its OS X operating system in the iPhone.

As last100 editor Steve O'Hear noted in reply to Jawad, "in terms of UI and the Web browser (WebKit), the two platforms have a lot of common ground, so comparisons are inevitable." Steve also pointed out that we'll need to wait and see "how open the iPhone actually feels to end consumers, and what restrictions carriers / handset manufacturers put on so-called Gphones -- they will be free to alter the Android experience as they please, so it could lead to a lot of fragmentation, leading to mixed user experiences and expectations."

Check out AndroidCommunity.com for pics and video. I think Android is looking very good so far, and we've already seen that there are a bunch of innovative apps being built for Android. Check out ReadWriteWeb's picks of promising Android apps.

That is where Android has a very good chance of usurping Apple -- web apps. Right now I use just a select few web apps on iPhone: RSS Reader, email of course, twitter... not a lot of truly mobile native apps (partly that's because of the network operators here in NZ, which still have high pricing and slow speeds). But if Android comes out with some new innovative Mobile Web apps, I'll be pretty tempted to switch -- well, maybe just buy another phone! I still love the iPhone :-)

Comment from Paul Johnson on 2008-05-29

2008-05-30T00:28:48Z

Apple will not allow Android to out-innovate it in the area of Mobile Web applications.

Comment from Ariki Gell on 2008-05-29

2008-05-30T06:14:28Z

Hi There,

In 2001 I got involved in open source and we could only dream of a desktop app! However, I did predict open source apps for mobile back then.

They key is its only a matter of time before they arrive, and not much time I might add due to the exponential growth that occurs with open source development.

How will New Zealand contribute, and importantly how will the New Zealand economy benefit. If the IDC survey is correct and open source will be worth US$50 billion in 2011, New Zealand should aim for at least 1-2% of that market, and lead the way with innovative open source mobile apps to test on our unbundled telecommunications market.

Comment from Tony Obregon on 2008-05-30

2008-05-30T11:33:15Z

The one big area where Android will kick serious ass over the iPhone is streaming video. I know that PacketVideo is part of the Open Handset Alliance and will ensure that all the pieces are in place for a rich, satisfying video experience.

Comment from Akira on 2008-05-30

2008-05-30T12:43:06Z

iPhone is already shipping

Android is late ...

Comment from Paul Johnson on 2008-05-30

2008-05-30T16:47:46Z

Tony Obregon: What?

http://www.phonemag.com/packetvideo-streams-mobile-tv-to-iphone-via-wifi-021019.php

Comment from Mark Sigal on 2008-06-01

2008-06-02T03:57:18Z

The chess game begins!

Earlier this year I wrote a post called 'The Chess Masters: Apple versus Google' that essentially asserted two things.

One that Apple and Google are without peers in terms of their ability to build products that cross the once impenetrable boundaries between PC, mobile, media and Internet segments.

Two that given their respective mammoth ambitions, ‘friends’ Apple/Google are destined to become ‘frienemies’ ala Apple/Microsoft (circa 1990).

It seems clear that Android versus iPhone SDK is destined to become a bonafide platform battle while at the same time both companies continuing to have lots of reasons to partner ala frienemies.

Check out the post if interested:

The Chess Masters: Apple versus Google
http://thenetworkgarden.blogs.com/we...ess-maste.html

Mark