Comments for YouTube Phasing Out Accounts, Google Login Will Be Required [Updated]

YouTube Phasing Out Accounts, Google Login Will Be Required [Updated]

2009-10-28T21:55:29Z

YouTube has begun warning users that they will soon be required to login with a Google account, instead of their old YouTube accounts. Just as people freaked out when Flickr changed the locks on the doors and required a Yahoo account to get in, you can bet that this is going to make some people very angry.

User generated content communities tend to have a very particular culture. If and when they get bought out, all kinds of issues arise around cultural differences and control. Seldom is this as clear as when old logins at a site are no longer accepted and users are required to get an account with the big powerful company that bought the community.

Update: YouTube contacted us after publication to clarify that this change is only required of people who previously chose to associate an additional Google account with their existing YouTube account and have continued to sign in with their old YouTube username and password. Those users will now be able to use either their YouTube username or their Google username but will be required to use only their Google password to log in. This is the kind of thing that happens sometimes when companies have to merge associated accounts for a single service - but people who haven't tied a Google account to their YouTube account will see no change. We apologize for getting the story wrong.

]]>

Chris Messina caught a screenshot today of a logged-in page at YouTube with the message: "Please start signing in with your Google password from now on. Pretty soon we will be phasing out support for signing in with your old YouTube password." Pretty simple!

We'll see if that warning ahead of time is helpful in calming the likely outrage by some users. YouTube is roughly four and a half years old - and it's been a Google property for three of those years! Maybe Google just now decided to keep it.

Will this be an opportunity for users to vent about overbearing copyright controls on background music, the rapid growth of commercial content on the site or other ways things have changed from "the good old days?" Time will tell. Given the small number of users who can even remember the pre-Google days, this transition might not be such a big deal.

Comment from Rob Colburn on 2009-10-28

2009-10-28T22:44:49Z

One of those has to happen sooner or later moves. We've got a few of those on projects we work on, where you have separate account systems. Google dodged around for 3 years.

Comment from andrea on 2009-10-28

2009-10-28T22:47:12Z

Will we keep our custom addresses? What if someone else has our custom xxyyzz@gmail.com youtube account: i.e. I am xxyyzz@gmail.com but Joe Blow is http://www.youtube.com/xxyyzz ??

Comment from Binary Age on 2009-10-28

2009-10-28T22:53:42Z

My theory: with social search Google is going to push people to reveal their social graphs whenever possible. YouTube userbase may be quite good source of social graph connections, why not associate them with google accounts?

Comment from Rich Hill on 2009-10-28

2009-10-28T22:58:43Z

I for one am sick of Google and their heavy handed methods of forcing us to expose all of our accounts to them in every single field that we work in.

I operate over 100 mostly niche blogs, and I also operate some Blogs for clients. I use different pen names for most of them, use different gmail and yahoo mail addresses for almost all of them.

There is no way in Hell that I want one market knowing what I do in another.

The same thing happened when they bought feedburner. I deliberately elected to lose all of my previous mail lists and RSS subscribers because I would not give up my ID to Google. they know too much about everyone as it is.

"Don't be Evil" seems like that would be a good slogan for Google to adopt.

I will move all of my many YouTube videos to Viddler and any other non-intrusive video hosting company that wants the traffic.

Color me not happy.

Comment from lauris on 2009-10-31

2009-10-31T13:16:45Z

This really sucks . Why should I join my youtube with gmail . if Someone knows my youtube login they can login into my gmail ???? This sucsk sucks sukcs

Comment from Tim on 2009-11-01

2009-11-02T04:35:41Z

lol

Comment from Zeke K. on 2009-11-03

2009-11-04T02:16:23Z

What if I already use the same password *and* username for both Google and Youtube? Will the service choke on this, and reject me?

Comment from Marianne on 2009-12-09

2009-12-09T23:12:53Z

Well, I've been happy to start signing in with my Google ID as soon as YT made it possible - one less username/pass combination to remember!
There's no privacy in cyberspace - anyone who gets online should know that. Paranoia only gets you high pressure and a headache.

Comment from Tarik on 2010-01-27

2010-01-27T12:52:27Z

I think that's a good thing.

Comment from Peace on 2010-03-13

2010-03-14T02:36:59Z

Hi.

I just say one thing. Start using something else than youtube. After I found out google linked my email to my searches and youtube account I'm looking to get out of this sick stazi style surveillance type of big brother system that google is running.

PEACE!