Scott Fulton's earlier post, What's This I Hear About Proprietary Open Source?, raised some interesting points about most people's idea of open sourced software. How open is open enough? If a project is closed to the public, can it really be called an open source project?

We asked and you answered and we culled your responses from the original post on ReadWriteWeb, Twitter and Facebook and used Storify to present it all back to you. If you have additional responses, please leave them in the comments.