ReadWriteWeb

Feedburner's new email subscription service impressive - but it's not game over yet

Written by Richard MacManus / April 19, 2006 4:24 AM / 4 Comments

feedburnerAfter my post that reviewed promising new email subscription services Zookoda and Yutter, I got an email from Feedburner telling me they had a new email service in the works. Tonight it was released - in fact you may have noticed it in my site menu earlier today. True to form, Feedburner's new offering is slick and took only a few minutes to set up in my Feedburner account and on my website.

The main features:

  • The emails are not branded, so they look as if they come from the publisher (and the reply-to email address is that of the publisher).
  • The publisher has full access to their email list, within their Feedburner account, and can export it anytime.
  • The email subscription form is cut-and-past javascript, which is easy for the publisher to implement.
  • The emails are delivered daily.
  • The HTML rendering of the blog content is very good, on a par with (even better in some cases) a normal RSS Reader.
  • It's a free service.
  • No subscriber interface in which the subscriber can manage things at FeedBurner.
  • No subscriber landing page on signup.

Those last two points signify that this is a publisher-centric offering from Feedburner and they're not attempting to be an email aggregator. This is in line with what Zookoda and Yutter are doing. 

Feedburner has existing partnerships with Squeet and Feedblitz (note: Phil Hollows from Feedblitz made some good comments in my previous post, in response to my criticism of them). But it's always made sense for Feedburner to integrate email into their service - and make it as publisher-friendly as possible.

feedburner
Sample of email

Feedburner's large user base and the fact that so many influential bloggers use their service already is going to make it tough for Zookoda and Yutter to make headway. Many bloggers, like I did today, will find it easier to just 'switch on' the Feedburner option rather than start a new account with an unknown service. Mike Arrington certainly thinks so.

However I'm planning to give both Zoodoka and Yutter a fair chance for my business, because I was impressed enough with their feature sets to want to trial them further. And I will, once I get some time to implement them on R/WW.

Of course now that Feedburner has entered the market with its own product, it'll be interesting to see how Zoodoka, Yutter and the others differentiate themselves. Zoodoka seems to have more advanced features than Feedburner, like creating custom email newsletters. And Yutter has some nice options too, such as blog branding, which Feedburner lacks. So despite the odds being stacked in RSS heavyweight Feedburner's favor, I'm not declaring Game Over just yet.

p.s. if you like this post, why not subscribe to Read/WriteWeb either by RSS - or email using this form:

Read/WriteWeb
by Email:


2 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2653

Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all Read/WriteWeb posts

  • Richard - I have a Feedblitz account and agree with Michael that I dont care of the branding on the emails that are sent. They could at least give you an option to turn it off. I am a Feedburner user and agree that having all of my syndication with one vendor is the best approach for me and with the ease of use what more could you ask for.

    Posted by: Dennis Bullock | April 19, 2006 9:35 AM



  • If you have a blog like I do where you want emails sent immedietely -- the blog is actually a community mangement tool used to make time-sensitive announcements -- daily emails are not enough.

    Posted by: kayvaan | April 19, 2006 12:09 PM



  • Disclaimer: I‚Äôm working closely with Axosoft on the next release of Squeet, which is due soon.

    Using Feedburner for email subscriptions is an excellent option for publishers that don’t mind:

    - non-compliance with CAN-SPAM;

    - providing their readers with a non-scaleable solution for rss to email, offering no way for readers to manage their subscription(s), define delivery options, or otherwise get the most out of rss to email;

    - setting the RSS movement backward by collecting email addresses…are you an email marketer or a blogger? What do you plan on doing with the email addresses? PRIVACY is an essential ingredient of RSS subscription.

    The bottom line, as far as Squeet is concerned, is that your readers shouldn’t be forced to choose between using a web- or app-based rss aggregator and a lack of privacy and functionality just because they happen to prefer email delivery. This disregard for readers can say a lot about a publisher, and will eventually become a stain on any feed that practices it.

    Look for Squeet’s upcoming new release within the next couple of weeks. It remains dedicated to providing the best product for publishers, readers, and the RSS community - one part of that is the commitment to moving rss forward by respecting the core value of personal privacy.

    Posted by: Angelo Coppola | April 19, 2006 12:45 PM



  • I just signed up to zookoda after your last post and am enjoying it immensley. I did actually see in feedburner the other day, with a sinking feeling, that this was all going ot be possible from one application... I hate changing services every five minutes :) But, like you we'll stick with zookoda for a while, it's pretty impressive

    Posted by: Natalie Ferguson | April 19, 2006 5:03 PM




RECENT JOBS



TEXT LINK ADS


RWW PARTNERS


RWW READERS


RWW POLL