ReadWriteWeb

5 Places Your Opinion Counts - Debate Site Roundup

Written by Josh Catone / April 28, 2008 12:03 PM / 13 Comments

While you're waiting for The Great Debaters to come out on DVD in a couple of weeks, there are a few places where you can put in some debate practice online in the meantime. One of the great things about writing a blog is that it is a platform for voicing your opinions. But it can also be rewarding to hear from the opposing side, and one thing we do often on this blog is ask for your views (as we did last week on the topic of video comments, for example). Below are 5 sites that organize debates around any topic.

CreateDebate is the newest debate site to hit the web. It moved from private beta to public late this morning and offers an extremely slick interface for online debate. Debates on CreateDebate can take multiple forms. They can be open ended questions, such as "Who had the best NFL draft?" or they can be head-to-head debates, such as "Is drug abuse a criminal or health problem, Yes or No?"

Users can vote in two-sided debates and add arguments in each. Arguments are voted up or down Reddit-style with the top arguments displayed at the top of the page. Users can also add rebuttals to arguments which can be further voted upon. Debates that are time sensitive (such as "Who will win the Democratic nomination for president?") can be set to expire. CreateDebate can also be used for simple yes/no polling on non-contentious issues.

One unique feature of CreateDebate is that each debate has a "research" page that pulls in news from RSS or Atom feeds. Whoever creates the debate can add new sources to the research page and news stories can be automatically made into the focal point of a new debate.

Riled Up! is a more simple debate site that uses the head-to-head format. Debaters are asked simple yes or no, or X vs. Y questions and asked to support a side. Choose wisely, because once you've picked your side, you can't go back.

Similar to CreateDebate, users vote arguments up and down and can post rebuttals, which can be tagged as supporting, neutral, or opposing.

Wis.dm is really a question and answer site that many have compared to Yahoo! Answers, but because it favors yes/no questions, it is actually more akin to the debate sites here. Wis.dm is set up very simply : Someone asks a yes/no question, users vote, and people debate the answer in an unthreaded discussion forum below the question.

The free form nature of the actual debate makes it a bit harder to follow everyone's position than on more polished debate sites, but Wis.dm is easily the most used of the sites in the round up. Its simplicity makes it very approachable and probably contributes to its mainstream appeal.

outQuib is a social network focused on debate and discussion that we reviewed in January. Debates on the site take the form of a poll with multiple response and forum-style commenting. But the focus of outQuib is really the social aspect -- debates are used as a means of connecting like minded people who can form groups on the site.

Jyte is a product of JanRain, makers of MyOpenID, and I get the idea that it is really more of a proving ground for their OpenID products than it is a serious startup. Jyte allows people to make claims (like, "Tiger Woods is the best pro golfer of all time.") and then people can vote to agree or disagree.

Users can also add comments to the debate (arguments for or against) and give each other "cred" points in areas they think a particular user is especially credible -- though it appears that cred points don't really amount for much other than bragging rights.

Conclusion

With the US presidential election kicking into high gear over the summer and coming to a conclusion next fall (barring any repeat of what happened in 2000), debate sites can probably expect to see a bump in traffic as people head online in search of places to argue their opinions. Which of the sites above is your favorite? Did we miss any? Let us know in the comments below.


1 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/3843

Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts

  1. CreateDebate looks pretty cool, it seems to have more features than the other sites listed. I also like how you can embed pics and videos in your arguments/comments.

    Posted by: dj | April 28, 2008 1:02 PM



  2. 1st! Ah Dammit!!

    Posted by: jj | April 28, 2008 1:35 PM



  3. I work for a startup called Minekey which develops iThink, which is a social networking application in this same space. I know you focused on stand alone sites here but thought it would also be worth mention iThink which is available on Facebook, MySpace, hi5 and Friendster. There plenty of discussions around the opinions that are being created there everyday. If you interested in learning more about, please contact me. Thanks.

    Posted by: Rajiv Doshi | April 28, 2008 1:36 PM



  4. Nice. I've been wondering about sites like these. Taking a stand on a controversial issue is a great way to make yourself known.

    Make some friends, make some enemies...


    Raza Imam
    http://SoftwareSweatshop.com

    Posted by: SoftwareSweatshop | April 28, 2008 2:17 PM



  5. Wis.dm Rocks!

    Posted by: Jenn | April 28, 2008 2:46 PM



  6. Great article! It's nice to see some folks are starting to evolve the traditional "message board" using some cutting edge technology. Should definitely facilitate better debate amongst folks instead of having to sift through all that nonsense that people usually post. Looks like CreateDebate is the most professionally done site out of the lot, but I'll keep my eye on them all to see how it plays out.

    Posted by: James | April 28, 2008 3:05 PM



  7. In the style of the later 3 is floort (http://www.floort.com/) where you post an opinion, voters can go agree/disagree/not sure and also comment. (you can mix and match, i.e. vot and not comment or comment and not vote.)

    Posted by: Steve | April 28, 2008 3:34 PM



  8. @Jenn CreateDebate Rocks!

    Posted by: kH | April 28, 2008 6:09 PM



  9. I still favor the pre-2.0 style debate forum like volconvo.com, where topics beside politics can be addressed. Heated debate still requires conscientious moderation to avoid becoming nothing more than a flame or spam fest.

    Posted by: Jack Carlson | April 28, 2008 11:12 PM



  10. I run a site (http://www.overrated-underrated.com) which is similar in that it allows users to express their opinion and debate whether something is overrated or underrated.

    Posted by: Kendall | April 30, 2008 9:06 AM



  11. Debatepedia is also something of interest to this dialogue. It's trying to be "the Wikipedia of debate". It's not so much about expressing your own opinion, but about documenting lines of argumentation and evidence in an encyclopedic form.

    http://wiki.idebate.org/index.php/Welcome_to_Debatepedia%21

    Posted by: BL | May 1, 2008 12:38 PM



  12. Rivals4Ever.com can be one of the site where people's opinion count. It can be a good place to show your passion for your support or idol.

    Disclosure: I am the co-founder of Rivals4Ever.com

    Posted by: Abhishek | May 21, 2008 10:23 PM



  13. I think it is a very good thing


    I will be helpfull

    Posted by: Richard poopy | May 22, 2008 6:47 AM



The ReadWrite Real-Time Web Summit
RWW SPONSORS


FOLLOW @RWW ON TWITTER

ReadWriteWeb on Facebook



TEXT LINK ADS