Spam filters are great but they aren't so good at determining subjectively important or controversial comments on blog posts. For example, we put up a post about Barack Obama's social media strategy right after the election. Our lead editors were all on flights back from the Web 2.0 summit and so we didn't notice that some of the comments on that post were really offensive and needed to be dealt with right away. Some technology to highlight and prioritize delivery of those comments in particular would be really nice to have.
This kind of automated prioritization of emails was something that Yahoo! was talking about a year ago in terms of an Inbox 2.0 concept but we still haven't seen it. The closest substitute we can think of is setting up a list of non-spam but high-priority keyword filters in GMail, then grabbing the RSS feed for that filter and subscribing to it in an app that we watch high priority feeds through.
When we write about companies, applications and concepts here, we try to provide some context by linking to related websites. That's just good blogging, we think, but it's much easier said than done.
This is the kind of technology we've fantasized about ever since seeing Austrian startup SystemOne at the DEMO conference in 2006. For now we rely instead on a collection of Google Custom Search Engines and that works very well.

Speaking of linking, we try to link out to other blogs as much as we can and we'd like to be linking to smaller blogs writing about concepts similar to our posts. Automation of that kind of research tool would be really nice and is something that SystemOne or BlogRovr could help with. Evri looks great from a publisher's perspective too, though it doesn't look as valuable from a research perspective as we'd like.
This author is just now checking out Zementa (see Sarah Perez's review this spring), which recommends related blog posts as you compose, but it's not clear that the recommendations are granular enough to be useful. We'll reserve judgment for now.
The best solution we've found to date is taking a Google Blogsearch feed for related keywords, changing the num=10 part of the URL to num=50 and then running that feed through PostRank. PostRank will take awhile to process it, but in the end you can see which recent posts about your keywords around the web got the most comments, inbound links, etc. That can help surface quality posts from sources you've never seen before.
We'd love to be shown related blog posts from our own archives as we compose new posts. We don't know if there is technology that can help do that better than the system we've already got. We simply bookmark the link to a google search for "site:http://readwriteweb.com," then visit that and add search terms to the query box. It works pretty well but relies on Google's algorithm for relevance. That may or may not be helpful.
This has been tried many times before and there are new people trying it now - but when someone creates a killer ranked, categorized and extensive directory of topic blogs around the web, they'll have the world at their door.
For now we've got a number of systems (six, actually) that work pretty well for us. Our favorite methods involve delicious and ask.com blogsearch.
It's a real good day around here when we get to incorporate some expert opinion in an article we write. We love doing that. We'd love to know which of our existing contacts or people we don't know would be best to contact regarding a story.
There is Help A Reporter Out and we should probably give that a try, but queries only go out a few times a day and we're looking for immediate contacts, preferably by Instant Messenger.
We've used Twitter for this a lot, actually, and in some ways it works better than we can imagine almost anything else working. If you're interested, check out our post How We Use Twitter for Journalism and see our favorite post written this way, APIs and Developer Platforms: A Discussion of the Pros and Cons. It's pretty amazing that nearly every quote we got for the story was sent to us on Twitter.
We love recommendation technology because used selectively it can make us smarter and more effective. The field is just in its infancy, though, and we expect that many of our dreams will come true soon.
What about you? Do readers here have recommendation fantasies, favorites or tips on getting done what we aim to do with the hacks and workarounds above? Drop those thoughts in comments and we'll all be smarter for it.
Photo credit: "I Love The Idea" Creative Commons by Flickr user apesara
Comments
Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts
These are the online recommendation tools that I've found particularly useful for teachers and students:
http://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/2008/07/24/the-best-places-to-get-blog-website-book-movie-music-recommendations/
That's a cool list, Larry, and for teachers too! Thanks for sharing it.
There are a number of search engines that find similar stuff that you might like to look at:
http://whoislike.it/
http://www.similicio.us/
http://web.insuggest.com/
http://www.tastekid.com/
The last is more music/books oriented, but the first three are all fairly good, though my preference is Whoislike.
We've got some stuff up our sleeves that will address a couple of these holes, though primarily in conjunction with partner sites. Feel free to ping me if you'd like to hear more.
For related companies, where a Wikipedia page exists for a company and companies similar to them, our demo site often does a decent job:
http://pedia.directededge.com/article/Twitter
http://pedia.directededge.com/article/Apple_Inc.
When it comes to bars and restaurants...
http://liketribe.com
...has indexed some popular restaurant guides like Citysearch and Yahoo! local for a few major cities. It uses the index to provide personalized recommendations using a collaborative filtering type approach. You can get started by rating just a few places, but the more you rate, the more accurate the recommendations get for your tastes.
Its location based, and boils your search down to only 3 suggestions. Best part is you can easily do it from your phone using text messaging or email.
Thanks for the pointer back to Blog Juice, Marshall; it's way past time I updated it to include FriendFeed and a few other services.
As of a few days ago, Yahoo! Mail will highlight messages from your Yahoo! Profiles contacts. One way to get priority notice about comments to your blog would be to send those messages "from" one of your contacts.
That's something we're trying to tackle at Skribit, although a full-realization of that might include some AI as well, which will naturally take quite a while to develop and fine-tune.
Thanks for mentioning Zemanta. One quick correction: it's ZemAnta.
There has been a lot of developments since the spring post from Sarah. We're recommending all related content (images, tags, links ...), not just related posts:
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/zemanta_releases_major_upgrade.php
We deliver the right content at the right time to the blogger.
Looking forward to hear your opininon. If you have any questions, please let me know.
Ales Spetic, CEO, Zemanta
aiderss/ postrank can show your 'best posts' in general... but not per topic. If you could create an rss feed per topic on RWW you could pump it through and get a 'best post' per topic
Crowley, you can do topic subscriptions with new postrank.com. Here is an example of a topic 'rss', with 'best' filter on it:
http://www.postrank.com/feed/2e39cadbd73de47e3427efc0e9ba31f5?q=rss&level=best
To subscribe to that feed, click the orange RSS icon, and you can export it to your favorite reader.
How about Megite Discover. Given a link, it can discover more related sites and posts under a concept.
Nice recommendation. See the stuff related to RWW.
@Ilya - thanks for the tip. That is an extremely useful new feature :)
Hey All,
I just found this blog using BlogRovr. I think its the best tool to use for an avid blogger like me.
If you have Firefox, you take a look at its deep plethora of add-ons and plugins that helps make the surfing experience a pleasant one. :)
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/4689
Let me know if you agree with me or not. :)
Regards,
Erwin
http://winning2win.com