ReadWriteWeb

Search 2.0 vs Traditional Search, Part 2

Written by Ebrahim Ezzy / July 25, 2006 2:17 AM / 3 Comments

Written by Ebrahim Ezzy and edited by Richard MacManus. Ebrahim is lead developer and co-founder of Qelix Technologies, the company behind a search 2.0 contender called Qube. This is the second in a 2-part series of posts.

Search 20

In our previous post we coined the term "Search 2.0", in order to compare third-generation search technologies (of, or pertaining to, the current era of social web) with traditional search engines - to see where the future of search lies.

Even if some of the startups we're profiling in this series may not survive the next Internet bust, the underlying ideas are evolutionary and have proven to be effective so far. We think the ideas showcased by these new social search apps are worth embracing, to ensure the future growth of the search industry. And, as we note at the end of this post, the big search companies (Google, Yahoo, Microsoft) think so too... 

Here then are some further profiles of search 2.0 apps, followed by our analysis of where the search industry is headed.

Gravee

graveeWhile the new generation of search engines all have great technology, one area of concern is that most have no viable business model to support their operations. However Gravee is one that does have an interesting business model. Indeed it is attempting to change the economics of search, by sharing advertising revenue with the content owners and compensating them for making search results possible.

While this is a potential revenue opportunity for website owners, it doesn’t provide any visible value to end-users on the search side - apart from pseudo-useful features like tagging and community-based ranking.

Unique Feature(s): Revenue sharing

Jookster

jooksterJookster is another community-driven, social search tool and it works primarily through a browser toolbar or button. It searches through a user's bookmarks and other associated sites of interest, derived from the user's social network. Essentially, it’s a cross between social networking and search.

Ironically, there are more ads than organic results to almost any query; perhaps the database is currently very limited due to the lack of significant user base.

Unique Feature(s): Social networking blended with search

Other similar services: Otavo (Private Beta); Outfoxed; Yoono

Krugle

krugleA search engine for developers, Krugle makes it easy to search for technical information, source code and answers to code-related technical questions. It enables searching of code samples from open source repositories, archives, mailing lists, blogs and web pages. It allows tagging, along with sharing of code and sets of search results.

Krugle delivers the precise help and knowledge that programmers need to solve their immediate problems.

Unique Feature(s): Interactive browsing in code context, Connects developers

Other similar services: Koders

LivePlasma

LivePlasmaLivePlasma is a visual music and movie discovery engine that covers bands, artists, movies, actors and directors - in a multilingual interface. It features a Flash-based data visualization tool and utilizes mind mapping. It's really a recommendation engine, because the aim is to discover similar music and movies. This may be useful when you're searching for new music or movies to explore. 

Unique Feature(s): Similarity Network Mapping or Mind Mapping, Recommendation engine

Other similar services: Truveo, Pandora, Last.fm

Qube

QubeQube is a desktop application that provides one-click access to search results - without having to use a browser, switch applications or even enter a keyword. It instantly searches any text already onscreen (or manually entered) and retrieves results in seconds, while also enhancing the search with features like real-time spell checker, history logging, dictionary results and more - all without any performance penalties.

Unique Feature(s): One-Click, Browserless & Progressive Search, Intelligent Text Capturing

[Disclaimer: Qube is Ebrahim Ezzy's company]

ZoomInfo

ZoomInfoZoomInfo scours the web (corporate websites, press releases, electronic news services, SEC filings and other public online sources) for people and their contact information. It compiles concise summaries about individuals and companies, in an organized manner. Social networking tools are available if you choose to be their customer.

With the growing Web population, there is a significant demand for a 'people search engine'. While TSEs like Google already contain large amounts of similar data, specialized people search engines process the data and present it in a comprehensive format.

Unique Features(s): Concise web summaries, Social networking aspects

So why use a Search 2.0 app over a TSE?

Traditional search engines are becoming increasingly more precise and expansive, however they cannot surpass human intelligence. It can only match words, not the meaning of the ideas discussed within them. Whereas the still-emerging technologies of S-2.0 can help make search more meaningful, subjective and task-based.

While TSE is good for finding information, S-2.0 is good at discovering new information at a rapid pace. 

S-2.0 enabled data is distributed through the lateral route of a user's interests - rather than the direct route of TSEs, which require a user to carefully craft his/her query to be an accurate statement of the information desired.

Can search 2.0 replace traditional search, ever?

Like metasearch, current S-2.0 technologies do not replace traditional search engines. They rather enhance and grow new possibilities. They work in conjunction with TSEs to provide a more powerful search.

Search 2.0 is rapidly evolving and proliferating, but still can't compete against traditional search. We have yet to see an application that blends the capabilities of Search 2.0 and traditional search synergistically, giving us exactly what we want. It’s likely that something will eventually replace TSE - perhaps there are two kids busy working in a garage as we speak, creating a future GYM competitor!

How is traditional search evolving to Search 2.0?

Perhaps a better way to look at this: how is traditional search evolving to become more personalized and specialized? 

Already we're seeing the big Internet companies moving towards the search 2.0 vision. Yahoo has a social search play called MyWeb 2.0 and is integrating more and more social aspects into its search. Google has quietly introduced bookmarking and tagging for search history and also has aspirations for social search. Microsoft's MSN is looking to get social too.

While the intelligence required to conduct social search still resides in people, the key to harnessing it lies in the network. TSEs have greater opportunities for traction, with their substantial user bases - a key ingredient of any social network. 

So this is more evidence that the latest search revolution is just getting started. Make way for social search!


Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts

  1. Nice informative article. My views on "2.0" things are starting to change... ;-)

    Did anyone ever recieve payments from gravee, 7% revenue share sould take long to generate even a couple of dollars.

    Posted by: Nikola | July 25, 2006 3:30 AM



  2. Nice summary and accurate definition of Search 2.0. Here are my understandings of search 2.0 vs TSE

    TSE:
    focus: machine
    Process: Information, strings
    tools: Information retrieval
    Results: large amount of web pages

    Search 2.0:

    focus: people
    Process: knowledge, concepts
    Tools: Machine learning, AI, Natural language understanding
    Results: accurate knowledge

    broadmining is one of the typical Search 2.0. It can provide concept association and classification and clustering.


    Try
    "tom hanks"
    You can get several groups of information.

    Try
    "tom hanks movies"
    "lakers players"
    you can get direct answers.

    Posted by: lowide | July 26, 2006 7:05 PM



  3. Another direction for Search 2.0 is searching via IM, like Quece which is in private beta:
    http://www.quece.com

    SearchEngineLowdown has a nice write up on Quece:
    http://www.searchenginelowdown.com/2006/07/quece-private-beta-launch-q-phrase.html

    Posted by: VGer20 | July 28, 2006 9:21 AM



RWW SPONSORS


FOLLOW @RWW ON TWITTER

ReadWriteWeb on Facebook



TEXT LINK ADS