ReadWriteWeb

Review of Streamy, a News Networking Service

Written by Phil Butler / July 15, 2007 11:07 PM / 10 Comments

Getting to the crux of Streamy, a very new beta startup, has proven to be more difficult than several prominent bloggers originally thought. I have been testing the development since Friday and awoke today to the news that Streamy is everything from a Digg competitor to a doomed social networking site. I was working late Friday, when the founders of Streamy Jonathan Gray and Donald Mosites messaged me to demo their innovation. Streamy is a beautifully designed site with an intuitive Web 2.0 interface. Streamy users can share, view, filter and drag-and-drop news stories, while communicating via a very slick chat module. On the surface, Streamy appears to be a "next generation" news networking site - but is it?

What Can It Do?

The UI at Streamy is simple and fairly intuitive. Users land on the start page looking at a basic three column layout tabbed with start, streams, people, profile and options. The start page is dominated by "What's Hot Today" content and graphic links to suggest or save feeds in each category. Users can change this view by navigating across 11 news topics, from arts to video games. In this aspect Streamy is not really differentiated from sites like Digg, Netscape or other news sites. What does differentiate Streamy though is the combination of  "function tabs", the sharing zones and the chat interface. These function fields and sharing zones do the following:

Streams - Saved, shared, comments, friend's shared streams, the subscription finder, saves - filters and create a filter

People - Friends, groups, status stream, friends of, location, profile editor, create a group and send an invitation

Profile - Accounts, subscriptions, comments, personal info, image, groups, friends, website launch, IM and etc.

Options - Streamy configuration including; environment, password, streamy theme and several enable options

Sharing Zones - Drop the dragged news to save, email or save the stories

This utility is a simple reorganization of the way we do things on other sites, but the drag and drop capability potentially speeds navigation and promises great sharing/communication capability. Accessing and manipulating stories is really what Streamy is all about and functions like this can easily go viral.

The personalization aspect is present, but secondary to the user's ability to communicate directly while sharing stories. In a nutshell - users can talk while dragging and dropping news into any number of fields from the chat module to group discussions. In the screenshot below I demonstrate Streamy's drop zones, dragging aspect, subscription finder and interactive chat module.


Point of contention - Streamy inside Flock with Me.dium sidebar

So, what is it?

Streamy is the product of two very talented programmers whose innovation is unfortunately caught in the midst of a blog frenzy. It is wholly inappropriate to label Streamy as anything like a Digg contender this early, and the resultant elevated expectations will only retard the product's progress. A similar destiny befell Flock when it was released and dozens of others as well. Streamy is a highly functional social news networking startup. Users have almost unparalleled on-site communication with the flexible chat interface and excellent customization tools. Streamy is a "preview" of a next generation social news networking site. What else could it be - the filtering aspect (which Don told me was the heart of the vision) is largely dependent on multi-user input.


Sharing Elena Sanrtarelli with friend DJ - gotta love day stamps

Pros

Streamy has great potential because of the power of Ajax and the news portal. Don showed me innumerable ways in which the drag and drop can be utilized to share, save and otherwise disperse news. The site is quite elegant - almost beautiful aesthetically - and their spatial organization is superb. The pop up versions of the selected news stories combined with browsing buttons, makes Streamy superior to nearly all news networks and especially Digg.

The chat module is really what sets Streamy apart. Even though a module like this would be a redundancy on other apps, it is a valuable instant communication and transfer tool on a viral news service like Streamy.

Cons

Streamy has a big problem in "the degree" of differentiation it has from other sites. My argument with Don is represented in the screens showing Flock and Me.dium, and I used them to illustrate that I could effectively do anything Streamy can do elsewhere. Streamy is not far enough along to get a true measure of its filtering capability, but it is evident that social news, drag and drop and chatting is not going to rock the civilized world. The navigation is fair, but a pretty steep learning curve detracts from discoverability - as Josh Catone and I discovered earlier today. The demo helps very little and a few clicks lead to dead ends all-together. Essentially, the site needs user feedback to be able to live up to their claims of "semantic" and advanced filtering. 


Browse friends feed and stream menu

Conclusion

This is a shoestring development by two very talented developers, but it is not Joost or the iPhone - nor does it have the backing to be like that yet. Streamy is simply not ready for predictions this early in the game (Digg competitor or your new start page?). However, if they don't differentiate themselves more - and soon - then they may well become just the next "flash in the pan" startup. It is not really good news when neither of the developers can substantially describe their vision or plan of development (as was the case).

After all this, how would I describe Streamy? It's a promising news networking site currently in private beta testing.

Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts

  1. very good review - mashable had a large one too.
    i guess the waiting times is a long one for an
    invitation to get. Im strained !

    Posted by: Pierro | July 15, 2007 11:30 PM



  2. I've not seen it yet but from the vids and reviews I can see huge utility in private networks for this sort of thing. In fact I can think of at least 2 networks I'm engaged with where this type of thing would have massive appeal.

    Posted by: Dennis Howlett | July 16, 2007 12:33 AM



  3. News feeds mixed with social networking sounds like it's got great potential

    Posted by: fi | July 16, 2007 12:51 AM



  4. Hey Phil,

    Excellent review as always, haven't had much to subscribe to new startups or do anything lately but Streamy sounds very promising and I already applied for invite and if you got any drop me some!!

    Posted by: M Jama | July 16, 2007 1:30 AM



  5. It is very hard for me to comment on something that I can not get access too.

    I do have one question, what niche is this product meant to serve? If you can do it all with other tools why use this one?

    Posted by: HMTKSteve | July 16, 2007 3:34 AM



  6. Great comments and thanks guys!

    Steve - that is a very good question. The niche is pretty full actually. Netscape, Digg and several other sites currently dominate the "social" news niche. Streamy hopes to be more social and inter communicative, while adding a dimension of semantic filtering/searching.

    It is a great idea and these guys are smart - I am just not sure if it is enough given the relative ease with which others could emulate it.

    I will see if I can get some invitations so our readers (at least some) can check it out.

    Posted by: Phil Butler | July 16, 2007 6:14 AM



  7. I wanted to try and get hold of Jonathan and Donald to discuss helping them with the launch of Streamy and offer my services as a web analyst and maverick marketeer... yeah I did just use those 2 phrases!

    Posted by: Adam Martin | July 16, 2007 8:54 AM



  8. I am getting a ton of traffic from Streamy ... I was wondering what it was. Thanks for the review.

    Sramana

    Posted by: Sramana Mitra | July 16, 2007 10:25 AM



  9. I'm just getting Steamy + Dreamy here looking at Elena Santarelli!!

    ;PPP

    I'm a bit out on these Digg like sites*

    I tend to use Original Signals which gives me the headlines from RWW + TechCrunch + Mashable + eHub etc*

    obviously there's way more news out there now of all types so Streamy might catch on*

    Posted by: BillyWarhol | July 16, 2007 2:20 PM



  10. if you get invites, I would love to have one. I have been obsessed with streamy ever since i first saw the video....But I have been very disappointed that they have been soo skimpy with there invites...

    Posted by: mike | August 1, 2007 8:06 PM



The ReadWrite Real-Time Web Summit
RWW SPONSORS


FOLLOW @RWW ON TWITTER

ReadWriteWeb on Facebook



TEXT LINK ADS