The Inner Circles of 10 Geek Heroes on Twitter
Hotshots, rock stars, geek heroes - many of us follow a lot of the same people online. But who do they pay the most attention to themselves? The influencers of influencers are of interest for a lot of different reasons, most appropriately because finding them is a good way to dive deeper into niche topics.
Twitter exposes conversations that can show us who's in anyone's inner circle because conversations there are public and programatically accessible. In the following post we look at the data and find out who has the most reciprocal conversations on Twitter with 10 geek heroes - from the founders of big sites like Digg, Reddit and StumbleUpon to nonprofit geeks working to challenge injustices.
There's something a little uncomfortable about being able to see this information. Fact is, though, it's part of the nature of this powerful new system of communication. We expect that data parsing like this is only the beginning.
In the charts below, assembled using developer Pete Warden's service Mailana, you'll see the top 5 people these geek heroes have reciprocal conversations with on Twitter and a screenshot of their larger web of connections. You can click through the links below to visit the full Mailana interface or visit this page to learn more about the methodology. On Warden's site you can click on the "info" links and see exactly what topics these friends discuss. There you'll see explanations like "@kanter sent 47 messages to @agahran and got 46 back." Note that these charts are just based on reciprocated public replies - not private direct messages.
If this post helps you get as excited as we are about Twitter, we hope you'll join us there.
Evan Williams
Evan Williams was the co-founder of Blogger and is now the co-founder and CEO of Twitter. He announced today that he's an expectant father! Who does he converse with most on Twitter?
1. Sara Morishige Williams, Ev's wife. Good man, Ev.
2. Chris Sacca, a startup investor and adviser to Twitter.
3. Jason Goldman, Product Manager at Blogger turned Product Manager at Twitter.
4. Biz Stone, Twitter's co-founder.
5. Sarah Lacy, tech business journalist (now on staff at TechCrunch) and author of the excellent Web 2.0 history book Once You're Lucky, Twice You're Good.
Here's Ev's full profile on Mailana. (Photo CC from Joi Ito.)
Veronica Belmont
Veronica Belmont is everybody's favorite geek video host. Who does she trade Tweets with the most? You might discover a person or two on her list.
1. Ryan Block, gadget blogging rock star and founder of Gdgt.com.
2. Tom Merritt, CNET podcast host.
3. Casey McKinnon, web actress and show host.
4. Patrick Norton, Veronica's co-host on Tekzilla.
5. Felicia Day, gaming web show host.
You can explore the Veronica-sphere here.
Kevin Rose
Kevin Rose, founder of social news site Digg, has long been one of the most-followed people on Twitter. More than 320,000 have opted-in to receiving Tweets from Kevin. He's following 160 people in return. Who does he have the most conversation with? Rose's list is unsurprising; it's mostly co-workers.
1. Gary Vaynerchuk of WineLibrary.TV.
2. Aubrey Sabala, Marketing Manager at Digg
3. Joe Stump, a developer at Digg.
4. David Prager, one of Rose's co-founders at web TV station Revision3.
5. Alex Albrecht, co-host of Diggnation.
You can see Rose's full list here.
Tim O'Reilly
Tim O'Reilly is the founder of O'Reilly Publishing and a related series of events like the Web 2.0 Conference. Here's who Tim has mutual conversation with on Twitter most often.
1. James Governor, an open source analyst at RedMonk.
2. Fred Wilson, one of the best known venture capitalists in the Web 2.0 world. Wilson has invested extensively in Twitter, for example.
3. Validis Krebs, the man behind Orgnet, a social network analysis and consulting firm.
4. Paul Kedrosky, writer and pundit on international finance.
5. Jennifer Pahlka, Web 2.0 Conference Chair.
Here's Tim's full profile on Mailana.
Shaquille O'Neal
Shaquille O'Neal hasn't always been a geek hero. The basketball great is fast becoming one, though, and if you haven't read about his awesome real-life meetups with Twitter friends, you really should. Shaq talks to all kinds of people on Twitter all day long (usually from his iPhone, it appears) - but who does he converse with the most?
1. Kathleen Hessert, a sports marketing Twitter pro.
2. A. Jo. Martin, Director of Digital Media & Research for the Phoenix Suns.
3. @laskey is someone with protected updates; we have no idea who this is.
4. Nate Moller, a marketing consultant.
5. Mona Mohammadi, Deputy to the Senior Adviser at the Office of Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, according to her LinkedIn profile, though that's not mentioned on her Twitter profile.
You can see all of Shaq's closest connections here, though he's such a gentleman we can imagine him taking offense at the idea that he loves any of his Twitter friends more than others!
Garrett Camp
Garrett Camp is the founder of StumbleUpon. StumbleUpon is awesome and Camp is a fairly consistent user of Twitter. Which lucky people get to engage with him the most?
1. Travis Kalanick is an entrepreneur who sold his P2P company Red Swoosh to Akamai in 2007. He advises and invests in startups.
2. Tim Ferriss is the author of the book 4 Hour Work Week.
3. Melody McCloskey, manager of video at Current.tv.
4. Gary Vaynurchuk, wine and social media man.
5. Zappos, Garrett Camp talks with his shoes.
Here is a full picture of Camp's network, though from the picture below you can see it's actually pretty sparse.
Alexis Ohanian
Alexis Ohanian is the co-founder of social news site Reddit. Reddit is old school and full of developers. Whom does its founder talk to most on Twitter?
1. Brad Parler, video dude at Powered Production.
2. Ian White is the creator of music sharing site Blip.fm.
3. Tony Adam, manager of search traffic acquisition at Yahoo.
4. Wil Wheaton, a famous guy who claims he disappoints everyone with his lack of responsiveness on Twitter.
5. Jacqui Cheng, Associate Editor at Ars Technica.
Here's the rest of Alexis' inner circle on Twitter.
Jeffrey Levy
Jeffrey Levy is the Web Manager at the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). He Tweets a lot, and well. Who does he Tweet with when he Tweets with other Tweeters?
1. Adriel Hampton works at the San Francisco City Attorney's Office and is a Goverment 2.0-head.
2. Ari Herzog is a strategic consultant.
3. Chris Dorobek, anchor at Federal News Radio.
4. Amy Gahran, a media consultant who was one of my (Marshall's) first web 2.0 heroes.
5. Dr. Mark Drapeau, Government 2.0 guy.
Check out the rest of Levy's inner Twitter circle here.
Jeremiah Owyang
Jeremiah Owyang has helped bring the stuffy world of corporate industry analysts into the Web 2.0 era of conversation as much as anyone has. He's got more than 36,000 people signed up to get his posts on Twitter, but there are some who he ends up conversing with more than others.
1. Peter Kim, former Forrester analyst with Owyang. Kim is now working on a stealth startup called the Dashis Corporation.
2. Jennifer Leggio, ZDNet social business blogger.
3. Shel Israel, Silicon Valley writer and communications guy.
4. Josh Bernoff, Jeremiah's fellow analyst at Forrester.
5. Amy Worley, VP of marketing at humor book publisher Andrews McMeel Publishing.
You can see the rest of Owyang's inner Twitter circle here.
Beth Kanter
Beth Kanter is one of the most inspiring non-profit tech consultants in the world. She's raised thousands of dollars on Twitter and has friends from everywhere. Who does she have conversations with more than anyone else, though?
1. Marnie Webb is the co-CEO at Compumentor/TechSoup. You should get to know Marnie; once you do you'll wonder why you waited so long.
2. Amy Gahran, see Jeffrey Levy's list above. Gahran has a lot of conversation with a lot of awesome people.
3. Jonathon D. Colman does SEO for REI.
4. Beth Dunn is a consultant and MBA candidate.
5. Dr. Mani is an Indian entrepreneur and heart surgeon.
There are a lot of people in Kanter's circle. You can meet some of them here.
That's a wrap!
We really like Pete Warden's site Mailana, where all these links and images come from, a lot. We like to combine Twellow and Mailana to find the most followed people in certain industries and then explore their circles of friends.
You should look yourself up on Mailana - you might be surprised who you converse with most often! The possibilities of these and all the tools that can be built on top of the wonderful Twitter API are nearly endless. Pretty interesting, is it not? Who's in your inner circle?
1 TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/10758
Facebook
Comments
Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts
Better leave room for Little Ev :~)
http://twitter.com/ev/status/1361281887
Nice post as usual Marshall
-@Ed
Nice to see Beth Kantor on this list!
This must have been one whopping amount of fun to write, almost as much as everyone else is going to have going to work on Mailana.
Wow.. that is a HUGE twitter post. Nice service - http://twitter.mailana.com/ - not sure how accurate it is though.
Rex
Wow Marshall, I'm really happy you dug so deep into Mailana. Apologies to everyone in advance if the server starts grinding under the extra strain!
Re: Accuracy - it's measuring how frequently you talk to someone else to guess at how close your relationship is. It's definitely not an exact science, it often misses people you don't bother twittering with because you see them so much, but it does seem reasonably useful.
I'd love to hear more back on everyone's experiences with the service, thoughts on its accuracy, feature requests and especially bugs! I'm @petewarden, say hello
"Rex, it should be as accurate as the Twitter API it's querying. One objection I've heard from people before is that "these aren't the people I've been talking to LATELY, maybe for all time" and this is pretty much all time. Check out the "help" page on the site for a URL hack to limit the conversation tracking to just the last 30 or 7 days. Those results might feel a little more familiar. If that's still not it, let me know."
Posted by: Marshall Kirkpatrick
|
March 20, 2009 5:18 PM
Rex, it should be as accurate as the Twitter API it's querying. One objection I've heard from people before is that "these aren't the people I've been talking to LATELY, maybe for all time" and this is pretty much all time. Check out the "help" page on the site for a URL hack to limit the conversation tracking to just the last 30 or 7 days. Those results might feel a little more familiar. If that's still not it, let me know.
This is a little off topic, but this jumped out at me - the presence of leaders of Digg, Reddit and StumbleUpon on a list like this indicates how much different the Web 2.0 marketplace is from everything that came before. Bill Gates reportedly forbids his family from using Apple products, but here we see major players from one social media site becoming celebrated users of another social media site. Amazing.
I like the way Malina does the lines around the people but I must say it's about 89% correct.
Here is my line of people:
http://bit.ly/jT7Kr
I'd love to hear more back on everyone's experiences with the service, thoughts on its accuracy, feature requests and especially bugs!
@vigosshong service is great I used it few months ago. Accuracy is pretty much good too.
I just posted about "Who are your Twitter BFF's?" http://tinyurl.com/d63ppu
@vigosshong - What's your annoying deal.
great article ..thanx for this
RWW awesome article ...
@peterwarden the site works real well for me ..
So far no issues ..
Amazing what twitter has done and will continue to do ,,
Thanks for including me! I'm amazed you picked me out of the crowd, but I appreciate it. I think social media has tremendous potential to improve government's role in serving the public, and that's my focus on Twitter.
If your readers want to help out, they can join the gov't Social Media Subcouncil's wiki: http://govsocmed.pbwiki.com
Thanks again!
Thanks for this - raising the issue about using Twitter to sustain or prop up an existing celebrity status is interesting. The being followed by 300 000 and following back a dunbar 150 ish is not good for twitter, I believe.
I just posted Twitter Long Tail - Broadcastization & Pre-Twitter Reputation that talks about this practice and how twitter is still pretty fragile and could be damaged by too many one-to-many entrants...lets hope it does not become passive reception from most and active broadcast from a few!
Marshall, very interesting and surprising to find out who your true inner circle is. A couple of things that I've noticed. It is historical, so your bff's from this month are probably very different than the historical chart. And if a friend has changed their name, all of that history and relationship will be lost.
Wow - Awesome post, and I'm on the list too! ^~~^
Thanks for the great post. Here's how I got Shaq to follow me on Twitter and how it's made a difference.
Thanks again for the mention.
Interesting, thanks for including me, I'm not surprised at all about my inner circle.
Love seeing how cross-platforms are embraced by the inner circles.
OK, first off -- Thank you for your high praise, Marshall!
Second, it's only 7am PT right now and I'm in the process of caffeinating, so I'm not going to try to offer substantive remarks just yet -- but Mailana seems to be an intriguing analysis tool.
Third, it seems to me that media has always been mainly about influence and connection. But we've kind of kidded ourselves that media is mainly about information or entertainment because we had better ways to measure content and distribution size rather than ripple effects.
What you've posted here is starting to look like a qualitative/quantitative ripple effect window... Hmmmm....
And I'll stop there for now until I'm adequately caffeinated...
- Amy Gahran
It's odd that you don't mention that Ryan Block is Veronica Belmont's boyfriend. You gave Ev and "attaboy" for tweeting to his wife, Veronica deserves the same kudo.
I guess we better get on twitter
How do people find time in a day to twitter so much, I have no idea, but I guess is a good thing.
Amazing article, i know who i should follow now.
I was sort of disappointed to see the location function of the search didn't work very well.
What happen to Guy Kawasaki? how come he's not in this list?
What a waste of time compiling this crap! I mean who cares who is talking to whom? You could have made a post about our crumbling economy and how to survive it, that will have more value.
I'm 13 & started my business when I was just 9 called Pencil Bugs. I've been really successful for a biz kid and have gotten lots of media attention and awards. But up until Dec. 2008, I wasn't on Twitter. What a difference in how fast things can happen because of Twitter. Schools should teach networking. They just don't get how important it is even for kids my age. Twitter is an education for sure. One day I'll be considered a Twitter Geek Hero. Watch for http://www.pencilbugs.com. It's going to be a mega empire.
"In the charts below, assembled using developer Pete Warden's service Mailana, you'll see the top 5 people these geek heroes have reciprocal conversations with on Twitter and a screenshot of their larger web of connections."
Posted by: Daniel J. Pritchett
|
March 25, 2009 2:32 PM
I found my list of BFF (people I converse with the most) was missing some of my closest Twitter friends who I talk with a lot. Maybe they aren't in the Mailana "system"? Also, it didn't have any of the people listed who I follow and who follow me in my location (New Jersey).
The best part of the application is clearly the social graph depiction, that is very cool! I especially like that the website allows the user to save a copy of it. It would be interesting to compare it over time as ones connections weaken or grow stronger and expand.
I just wish some of my best friends were included and I can't figure out why they are left off when other people I hardly ever talk to are listed.
ugg boots 50-70% Off All Boots, 100% Original. UGGS australia, Fast Delivery! Money Back Guarantee! Buy it now!!!
that is awesome list, and such a great simple top 5 list and the social connections chart
yeah i follow some of those alrite. tweet on geeky fellas!
I Twitter!
There's something a little uncomfortable about being able to see this information. Fact is, though, it's part of the nature of this powerful new system of communication. We expect that data parsing like this is only the beginning.