ReadWriteWeb

The Talking Search Engines: A Conversation with HAL

Written by Charles Knight, AltSearchEngines editor / April 11, 2007 1:52 AM / 9 Comments

"Good Morning, HAL."

"Good Morning, Charles."

"You were out pretty late last night, HAL."

"I went to a party."

"Oh.  Who was there? Any bots that I know?"

"Just friends; the usual chatterbots."

"Was SHE there?"

"Who?"

"Oh come on, HAL, you know who I mean.  Was Ms. Dewey there?"

"Yes. She was with some bot."

"Who?"

"OLIVER somebody."

"You know she's a human, don't you HAL?"

"What are you talking about, Charles?"

"Ms. Dewey, she's a human actress that plays a robot.  Her real name is Janina Gavankar."

"Your pulling my cables."

"See for yourself, HAL, her website is www.janinagavankar.com."

"I need to think about this, Charles.

"I understand.  Isn't it ironic, HAL? Usually it's us who are treating robots like humans. This time it's a human acting like a robot!  Who else was there?"

"Oh, the usual crowd. ALICE and ALAN arrived together."

"What about Foxy Voxy? I know you like her."

"Her name is ASK VOX, and I'd appreciate it if you didn't call her that."

"Sorry HAL.  Who else?"

"Some bot named Daya."

"Is that a male or female bot?"

"I'm not sure."

"What do you mean, you're not sure?"

"Well sometimes it had a male voice, but sometimes it sounded female."

"You think it was bilingual? Not that there's anything wrong with that."

"Of course not. And Promo was there. What a bore!  All he could talk about all night was SEO, SEO, SEO."

"Maybe he's just programmed that way HAL."

"Maybe."

"There was this really cute new bot...her name is Abby."

"What's her story?"

"Well, as near as I can figure out, you give her a phone number and a text message, and she'll call your friend and deliver your message in that pleasant voice of hers."

"Did she give you her number HAL?"

"You're a riot.  Heather Accoona, the talking toolbar, was there too."

"Don't you have to download her?"

"Hey, watch your language!  She happens to convert any web page text into female speech - for your benefit, I might add.  Robots don't need human voices to communicate, it fact it's extremely slow for us, but we do it because it pleases you."

"Alright, I'm sorry HAL.  Don't get your bytes all in a bunch.  What about that new bot, was it there?"

"You mean TellMe? She's with Microsoft now, you know - they just got hitched. Besides, she's just a glorified telephone operator.  You know, call 1-800-555-TELL and all that. A regular Emily Litella!" [HAL laughs]

"No, no, not her. I mean the new one, you know, from THERE."

"Where?"

"You know, from Mountain View."

"Oh, from Google. You're thinking of Google's Voice, 1-800-GOOG-411.  Yeah, he was there. Mr Big Shot, thinks he's so cool!  He's no different than TellMe; you call a number and you say 'Chicago. Pizza.' And it reads you some Yellow Pages ad. Big deal!"

"Are you jealous, HAL?"

"Jealous? Are you kidding?  That's like being jealous of Speeglebot! If that's as far as you humans have gone with AI, you're in sad shape my friend. 'Pizza!'  Give me a break!"

"Seriously, HAL, do you think there will come a time when humans and computers can talk with each other?"

"Like this?"

"Yes, like this."

"Why do you want to? So you can drive a car like K.I.T.T. around and impress female humans?"

"No. Although..."

"Or is it because you want some fool bot guarding your house, yelling 'Danger Will Robinson!' every time a dog crosses your yard?"

"Hey, calm down, HAL, it was just a question."

"Well it drives me crazy. Google could index all of human information and deliver a relevant answer to your search query in a fraction of a second, and you humans would still complain because it doesn't chat with you!  If you want to talk with a robot, why don't you go see ELIZA, the Computer Therapist?"

"Okay. Okay. Maybe I will. But you know HAL, it's not just an anthropomorphic fantasy, there are some real issues here."

"Like what?"

"Well, look at the research of Dr. Helen Smith, she just wrote an article entitled At least Google listens.  Apparently some men are so 'socially challenged' that they would rather come home and interact with their computers instead of their spouses or girlfriends."

"Like this?"

"Funny, HAL.  But I'm trying to be serious."

"Go ahead."

"Thank you. Dr. Smith (not the Lost in Space Dr. Smith, it's Helen Smith) has found in her work with violent teens that we modern, or should I say post-modern, humans actually tend to dehumanize each other; so much so that a computer that, well, just listens without making - or even has the capacity to make - moral judgements - no offense HAL --"

"None taken."

"-- that computers can actually seem sympathetic by comparison.  And a computer that can both understand human speech and return results in human speech might be more human, than, well, than a human.  I think. Do you know what I mean? And I'm not talking about some disembodied voice telling me where the nearest Pizza Hut is.  Maybe it will be Hakia or Powerset or Cognition or Subjex or Lexxe or AnswerBus or SurfWax... but that day may come."

"That's a lot of, how do you say, "alternative" search engines to keep track of Charles. How do you propose to do it if I'm not here to help you?"

"Well, HAL, it just so happens that I have this list.....

"Good night, Charles."

"Good night, HAL."


1 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2122

Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts

  1. very nice post and some interesting issues raised. maybe the author can give a few more links to recent research on AI on the Web and on how humans seem to focus more on computer interactions rather to human-human interactions

    Posted by: Nicolas R | April 11, 2007 2:42 AM



  2. ...So you can drive a car like K.I.T.T. around and impress female humans?" - topical

    Nice article, and good to see a different and not-dry approach to links/reviewing, on ya.

    Posted by: Mike Riversdale | April 11, 2007 3:26 AM



  3. Nice Charles...I sometimes use this approach but never so extensively. It's a different twist but the points come through.

    On the matter of these talking search engines...I feel we still have a very far way to go. I have tried a few...let's just say that a lot more "training" is in order.

    I think there is an unresonable amount of obsession because of what we have seen in movies...but we all know most users have little patience for impracticality.

    Posted by: Adrian Keys | April 12, 2007 8:07 AM



  4. A note to readers: The more "robot" links that you click on, the more of the actual projects that you can see (or talk to).

    Please note: If you click on ALAN, you can ask him to let you speak with HAL. That's how you can speak with the HAL9000.

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 12, 2007 8:11 AM



  5. Re: Comment #1 Nicolas, I hope that someone from M.I.T. will post a comment proving me wrong, but I noticed a strange trend when I research these talking bots. Most of the projects above are from the period 1990 - 2000. So obviously I sought out more advanced bots from 2000 - 2006, and didn't find any.
    Are they secret? Did they give up? Am I a poor researcher?

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 12, 2007 8:26 AM



  6. Re: Comment #1 Nicolas, I hope that someone from M.I.T. will post a comment proving me wrong, but I noticed a strange trend when I research these talking bots. Most of the projects above are from the period 1990 - 2000. So obviously I sought out more advanced bots from 2000 - 2005, and didn't find any.
    Are they secret? Did they give up? Am I a poor researcher?
    Then in 2006 - 2007, Ms. Dewey, ASK VOX, AbbyMe, Tellme, etc.

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 12, 2007 8:28 AM



  7. Re: Comment #3 Adrian, as for movies and TV, I believe they exist because we want them to; in other words I don't think we saw a movie or TV show and said, "That's it - I want that." I think the producers were just delivering what we *already* wanted. And boy do we want it! Just look at the I, Robot series by Isaac Asimov - this desire has been around for as long as computers have been around.

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 12, 2007 8:34 AM



  8. Author's note: One thing that I left out of the conversation with HAL is the famous "Turing Test." To pass the Turing Test, a human must converse with two curtains - behind one curtain is a human, and behind the other curtain is a robot.

    If the first human cannot tell which voice is the robot's and which is the human's, then the robot is said to have passed the Test. Even though IBM's Deep Blue computer beat the #1 human chess player, how many readers feel that a computer will ever pass the Turing Test?

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 12, 2007 8:40 AM



  9. Did you ever get the feeling that you were just talking to yourself? Oh, well...

    If you read this and you have just read about the past and the present state of voice search, please go here to see the video on The Future of Voice Search:

    http://gigaom.com/2007/04/12/future-of-intels-ultramobile-pc/

    Posted by: Charles Knight | April 13, 2007 10:21 AM



The ReadWrite Real-Time Web Summit
RWW SPONSORS


FOLLOW @RWW ON TWITTER

ReadWriteWeb on Facebook



TEXT LINK ADS