ReadWriteWeb

Web Email Market: An Overview

Written by Richard MacManus / August 15, 2006 10:08 PM / 17 Comments

Webmail.us has just released the fourth generation of its Web Email platform, replacing its legacy software with an AJAX framework. They're promising their users "a markedly faster, better performing experience" with its new Ajax version. Webmail.us provides email hosting services to more than 23,000 small-medium businesses and is one of a number of smaller, niche companies in the Web email market.

Now you'd think the giants - Microsoft, Google and Yahoo - would be totally dominant in this market and so there'd be little chance for the little guys? Hotmail/Windows Live Mail, Gmail and Yahoo! Mail all have huge user bases. But there are (as always) ways for the smaller companies to compete. Indeed it's comparable to the Personalized Start Page space, where small companies like Pageflakes and Netvibes are finding profitable niche markets - despite the presence of the big portals with similar products.

So in this post, let's take a high-level look at the Web Email market. My thanks to Webmail.us CEO Pat Matthews for talking to me about this.

The consumer market is fairly clear cut and dominated by Yahoo and Microsoft in particular (Google's Gmail is competitive too of course, but more on that below). In terms of the enterprise and small business market, Pat said that most organizations are running some sort of email server to provide employees with business email. Microsoft Exchange is the 800 pound gorilla in this market and there isn't a clear #2. However, Pat noted that competition on the rise for MS Exchange - especially in open source and the service provider markets.

Here then is a list of some of the companies in the Web email space:

Zimbra

zimbraZimbra is getting a lot of buzz and some real traction in the marketplace. Their product is a lot more than just email - it is essentially a mini-suite of Web Office products. The Zimbra Collaboration Suite has email, contacts, group calendaring, word processing and spreadsheets. The latter two were just added this week, as part of the launch of Zimbra Collaboration Suite (ZCS) 4.0.

In my full review of Zimbra back in April, I was impressed that Zimbra is packed full of features. They have mashups and things like "Search Builder" and an RSS reader.

Zimbra has an open source component to their business model, whereby the software is open sourced and they generate revenue by supporting deployments of the open source software platform - as well as a network edition. Zimbra may be a good alternative to Exchange for businesses that want desktop software, but don't want to pay the high licensing fees associated with Exchange.

Webmail.us

webmailusWebmail.us differentiates itself from Exchange and Zimbra by being a 100% hosted email model. Pat told me their customers prefer to outsource the hardware, software and security services (anti-spam, anti-virus, etc.). In the words of Pat, their customers "want to get rid of the software model altogether."

But how then does Webmail.us differentiate itself from the bigco Web Email services, not to mention web hosts and ISPs? Pat said there are three "philosophical ways" in which Webmail.us is different from the likes of Gmail and Yahoo:

"1) email hosting is all we do;

2) there is a large service component to our business; and

3) our services are subscription based as opposed to advertising support (we're completely ad-free)."

Gmail

gmailGmail is my personal favorite Web email product, because of its innovative and Web-native features - such as search and "conversation view". Admittedly Gmail has more of a techie following than any of the other service providers, so in that respect it's struggled to gain mainstream adoption - in comparison to Hotmail or Yahoo Mail.

Earlier this year Google announced a beta Enterprise service, unimaginatively named 'Gmail for your domain'. It is basically Gmail offered as a back-end service and Google provides all the required hardware and software. Each enterprise end-user gets 2 gigabytes of storage, the same as consumer users of Gmail currently. Plus there's access to Google Talk (VoIP/chat), Google Calendar and a Control Panel to manage accounts.

Sproutit

sproutitSproutit is a startup that offers business software to small businesses. Sproutit has an interesting product called Mailroom, which is a hosted email management service. Where Mailroom is different is that it enables you to "organize your email and suggest replies to save you time and keep you better in touch with your customers." So it helps companies use email to keep track of sales leads and customer communications, which makes it as much a CRM tool as an email hosting service.

Yahoo Mail

yahooThe new Ajax version of Yahoo Mail is currently in beta. Like all the other Ajax webmail products, this enables it to mimic the functionality of a traditional desktop email app. Indeed Yahoo Mail sticks to the traditional email interface, but it has some innovative features too - such as integrating RSS. More PIM features are coming soon, as revealed in my recent interview with Yahoo's Bradley Horowitz (VP of Product Strategy) and Caterina Fake (leader of the Technology Development Group). Along with Hotmail, Yahoo Mail has a huge user base - well over 200 Million unique users.

Hotmail / Windows Live Mail

live mail Windows Live Mail is the replacement for Hotmail, but is still in beta and only available in certain countries right now. According to Niall Kennedy's review back in November, it has been written from the ground-up to replicate a desktop application look and feel. It has Ajax, of course, and a similar user interface to Outlook. It is a three-column view and has access to calendar, contacts, and your "Today" view. Formerly code-named 'Kahuna', Windows Live Mail will replace Hotmail once it is complete.

Hotmail, one of the original webmail products, was launched in '96 and acquired by Microsoft in '97. But its day has past.

Summary

CNET recently did a comparison of the bigcos web email apps - concluding that Gmail is the best in terms of functionality. I agree, but would add that both Yahoo and Microsoft are catching up fast! Gmail has to be acknowledged though as the product that pushed Web email into the 21st century, with its Ajax interface and large storage capacity. Gmail basically forced the hand of Yahoo and Microsoft to follow suit with their own Ajax Web mail products.

In terms of the small companies battling for a niche in the Web email ecosystem, Zimbra, Webmail.us, Sproutit - and I'm sure many others - all have their place. While the bigcos will continue to dominate the consumer market, none of them yet have a compelling Web email product for the enterprise or small business market - so that's where the likes of Zimbra and webmail.us will shine.


1 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2716

Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts

  1. FYI, as a paid hosted small business email and collaboration solution, BlueTie has more users than Zimbra and Webmail.us combined and offers full exchange functionality including AS/AV, IM, GB email and shared file storage, shared calendars (iCal compliant), shared contacts, secure encrypted large file transfer and a complete administrative function, full sync with Outlook, etc.
    I hate to use blog comments to pitch but we've been out here with an extremely integrated product way past beta, lots of AJAX functionality, etc. Check it out.

    Posted by: Martin Edic | August 16, 2006 11:23 AM



  2. I would hardly consider Pageflakes and Netvibes to occupy profitable niches. Both companies are loaded with debt and cash flow negative, trying to "landgrab" now to monetise later. Start Pages aren't profitable YET.

    Posted by: Sharpshoot | August 16, 2006 11:47 AM



  3. Awesome article.

    You may be interested in the top 6 free webmail that have 1+ GB of storage. I found this pretty interesting.

    http://chronicles.weblogs.us/2006/08/04/top-6-free-webmail-1gb/

    Posted by: Thomas | August 16, 2006 9:31 PM



  4. JoyEnt Connector also deserves a nod. Like Sproutit and Zimbra, but with a different (and IMHO better) way of sharing what you create among teams.

    Posted by: Wavesplash | August 17, 2006 1:44 AM



  5. Yeah ! Maybe they are on red... But just for a while I bet they will pay their investment soon. We must enjoy the service now, at the moment i use pageflakes , i think their services is really good comparing with other startpages.

    Posted by: Marcus | August 17, 2006 5:43 AM



  6. it certainly took yahoo and microsoft a while to do a bit of catching up. kind of disappointing, really.

    Posted by: Hans | August 17, 2006 2:24 PM



  7. I just want to let everyone know that we're going to be releasing Litepost in the near future:

    http://www.litepost.com

    It has a number of compelling technologies (including some new "killer features") that kick the pants off *ALL* the existing email providers.

    I hope you do not regard this message as spam, it's more like fair warning (!). :)

    Posted by: Nathan | August 17, 2006 2:25 PM



  8. Why no mention of AOL's offerings in this space. Admittedly until recently their mail is for paying subscribers (i'll leave aside the aim namespace version which has been available and free for awhile). My opinion of their web based mail is not very high nevertheless they are still a major player in the space especially given their recent move away from the ISP side of the business,

    Posted by: Julio | August 17, 2006 2:32 PM



  9. I prefer Gmail, even if it does not have some features of the other services. Clean layout is much more pleasant for stressed eyes, I think.

    Good mail comparison, well done !

    Posted by: Maria loves pictures | August 17, 2006 2:48 PM



  10. You know, for a website 'reviewing' cutting-edge web applications, I'm surprised you write AJAX as 'Ajax'. It's an acronym. Ajax is something you find under the sink. AJAX is what runs these new webmail applications.

    Good article for the most part, though.

    Posted by: Avinash | August 17, 2006 3:14 PM



  11. Ah, actually it is written as "Ajax". Check the official source, Jesse James Garrett, who coined it:
    http://adaptivepath.com/publications/essays/archives/000385.php

    :-) It is an acronym though, so a bit confusing...

    Posted by: Richard MacManus | August 17, 2006 4:13 PM



  12. An excellent webmail service and more is www.goowy.com I now use it to access my pop3 email from my ISP, and it works with all the big guys (hotmail, gmail,yahoo etc.) I have been using it since they launched and haven't seen anything as else as good from a UI experience.

    Posted by: Alex | August 18, 2006 5:46 AM



  13. "Gmail basically forced the hand of Yahoo and Microsoft to follow suit with their own Ajax Web mail products."

    Yeah, Ajax was really Gmail's ace in the hole. I expect the competition will fold. Besides, Google's the only one playing with a full deck.

    *sigh*

    Posted by: Kozz | August 18, 2006 9:28 AM



  14. I prefer Gmail to others. Tried Yahoo! beta, but it is far slower than the previous non Ajax version.

    Gmail is slow during the first load only. Yahoo!, on the other hand, lags in almost every operation.

    Anybody have the same experience?

    Posted by: Hendry Lee | August 20, 2006 11:00 PM



  15. Nice post, Just what I was looking for. Trying to evaluate tools nowadays is hard. Gmail would work for me if I could share Contacts between users, the way I can with calendars. Yahoo Beta is a step forward, but too slow and too many ads.

    Zimbra is a candidate. I'll try some of these other ones I see mentioned here. A quick peaks reveals some interesting alternatives.

    Posted by: Austin Real Estate | August 21, 2006 2:33 PM



  16. Nice post. But how is it you can miss one of the biggest webmail providers? aim.com and aol.com are both free and something like third or fouth biggest in the world. They are also quite good.

    Posted by: Alan | August 23, 2006 4:16 AM



  17. I never see any comments on INDREDIMAIL email. We have used it for years & it is SO easy to use & has all the bells & whistles, except I can''t seem to view it when I''m away from home. Are there any comparison charts whith Incredimail? I really hate to give it up. We have had NO problems with it, but there are times I'd like to view when away from home.

    Posted by: Kathy Degelmann | September 6, 2006 10:54 PM



The ReadWriteWeb Online Community Management Guide
RWW SPONSORS


FOLLOW RWW ON TWITTER




RECENT JOBS



TEXT LINK ADS