Zoho App Selection Explodes With Platform - But Are These Apps for Real?
If you're familiar with Zoho, the online office suite for small and medium sized businesses, you probably know that they offer a whole lot of different applications. The 16 different apps the company has had for some time seems like a small selection now - today the Zoho Marketplace launched with hundreds of new apps built on the company's platform Zoho Creator.
Developers can build their own apps for free or for sale and Zoho allows them to keep 100% of the revenue from app sales. Are these apps for real? It's hard to say. We really like the idea, but Zoho is a complicated company.
The Marketplace Apps
As can be imagined, there's a wide range of quality in the apps in the marketplace today. In its announcement Zoho says that more than 100,000 apps have been created with its Zoho Creator database program, but it appears that only about 300 of those are included in the marketplace at launch.
It's hard to know how to find the best apps, to know which ones are effectively duplicates and we expect those issues to continue as developers flock to the platform. It's one thing to rustle through scores of sheep kissing apps on Facebook, or shiny GPS baubles in the iPhone platform - it's another to try and find apps in an office marketplace to run your business on.
Some of the app demos were loading only intermittently during our evaluation and that's not a good sign for something users are going to do business with.
Some, like HelpDesk, look strikingly robust. Others, like the very similar Issue Tracker, look downright insufficient - Issue Tracker's bug tracking app doesn't offer reporting as far as we could tell, for example.
Most of the apps in the marketplace right now are free. The variety of apps available is interesting; one called Camp Registration facilitates registration for events, includes an hour of customization and costs $150. That app can be embedded on any other website. This and all the apps in the marketplace offer a demonstration you can view before installing.
To some degree your trust in Zoho marketplace apps will likely begin as a matter of faith. Readers here presumably are willing to put some amount of trust in online apps in general. There's probably a little more skepticism about Zoho apps in particular. Zoho marketplace apps, developed by people outside the company all together, will be an even further leap of faith. Whether you can make that leap will depend in part on where you started regarding online apps in the first place.
Zoho Apps in General
Google's online office apps were expected to change the world, and by some limited accounts they've begun to. Many people, though, find Google Apps too lightweight and infrequently updated.
Zoho's office suite has faced criticism about being too lightweight but no one can say they are too infrequently updated. A July report from analyst firm the 451 Group reported that Zoho was slowing down on new product roll out and would be focusing on improvement of existing apps. That prediction appears now to be incorrect, but the rest of 451's analysis of Zoho is very useful. "At present, there's still something of a work-in-progress feel about Zoho, with some key functionalities still to come," report authors China Martens and Anne Nielsen wrote.
Ask any major CRM vendor who they're keeping an eye on in their rearview mirror, and Zoho will be among the first players they name. That's pretty impressive for a vendor that has largely relied on word of mouth and user experimentation to gain notice...The company is already well positioned to address the increasing app pricing and integration pressures from customers and has made some initial strides in establishing channel sales.
According to another report from analyst firm Yankee Group though, Zoho already offers a better enterprise collaboration suite than Google. That report tracks 16 collaboration suites head to head, further comparison results still pending.
Zoho tells a good story and is certainly an exciting company to watch, but sometimes the story gets a little more oomph than it deserves. Oliver Marks at ZDNet, for example, wrote this week that a story floating around the blogosphere that General Electric dropped Google Apps in favor of Zoho was not in fact true. Marks reports that GE is still evaluating both services and hasn't made a decision yet about either.
Conclusion: These Apps Will Work for Many People, But Not All
We love platforms, good ones are fascinating in their fecundity even if they are complicated for providers and participants. Zoho does have a lot of momentum in the small business world, so we expect there to be a lot of international developer interest. Will customers come to Zoho and stay? The price and selection are hard to beat so the company will likely win customers for whom those are primary concerns. Would-be customers who prioritize robustness may have a more mixed experience, depending on the apps they select from the marketplace.
Comments
Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteWeb posts
Very good write-up on this Marshall. Zoho is an interesting and complicated company as you stated. I watched a video interview of the CEO with Skoble and that was pretty compelling as well. I couldn't figure out why they had taken on the hosting component themselves. They are managing 800 servers themselves! Seems rather ambitious for a Web 2.0 company. Again, it is interesting how complicated they have made things. I am watching this company go forward and wondering where they will eventually end up!
Posted by: Troy Malone | September 30, 2008 12:04 PM
Thank you for your write-up. We had some opening day glitches - basically some optimizations had not been turned on for most of the applications - which we are sorting out. We understand how important quality of service is for our customers, and we have invested heavily in infrastructure to handle the load.
Sridhar Vembu
Zoho
Posted by: Sridhar Vembu | September 30, 2008 12:31 PM
RE: "More than 100,000 apps have been created with its Zoho Creator database program, but it appears that only about 300 of those are included in the marketplace"
The platform has been used for some time to host custom programs. Any user of of Creator might have made their own program and it is not unusual that only 300 of those would be released publicly so far.
RE: "It's hard to know how to find the best apps"
Helping users find and share info on the best apps is the most important goal for Zoho now (besides keeping their servers running smoothly).
The user community will also try to address this, and Zoho should look for ways to help them.
RE: "Google's online office apps"
Google Apps is similar to the Zoho suite, and Google App Engine is similar to Zoho Creator. They are both designed to allow custom programs and database-like storage systems within the hosted environment.
RE: "Google Apps too lightweight and infrequently updated."
This is definitely a problem with Google Apps, because new feature
Posted by: mchelen.myopenid.com
|
September 30, 2008 8:12 PM
today the Zoho Marketplace launched with hundreds of new apps built on the company's platform Zoho Creator.thanks.
Posted by: sevgisohbet | October 1, 2008 4:29 PM
I don't completely agree with the author's statement that "Many people ... find Google Apps too lightweight and infrequently updated." Yes, the Zoho Marketplace model is interesting; however, for core applications like word processing, spreadsheets and e-mail, would you trust just any developer?
I've been an active Premier Google Apps users for some time now and have found the applications to be stable and robust enough. True, they're not as powerful as their Microsoft Office equivalents, but how many people use even 10% of all the functionality?
For those that remain unconvinced, check out this online video, Google Apps: Quick Tour for an overview of the Google App Suite.
Posted by: JV | October 1, 2008 6:17 PM
I have ben a user and a fan of Zoho apps for two years now. What I love about the company is their energetic and ambitious modesty. They clearly love computing and kool apps. But they also clearly love their users. I have seldom dealt with a company so assiduous in getting feedback , taking it seriously, and making apps better because of it. People who take a skeptics p.o.v. about Zoho as a business model miss the most important thing about these folks--they love computing and really want to make the world a better place than they found it! They are unfailingly polite, solicitous for your welfare, and eager to make a better mousetrap. Take Creator, for instance: this one app has made me look like a computer genius on several occasions--when I barely know one end of a program from another! And it keeps getting better. It's a big world out there. Zoho sees the billions (literally) of people who are not yet users of productivity apps because they can't afford to plunk down $150 for basic MS Office suite--but they constitute the largest growth market in the coming decades. I am happy to benefit from this "tail"! If you haven't tried Zoho apps, you really should. They beat Google hands down--with the exception of Google Notebook, which for ease of use is tops. And they just keep coming with mor and better apps.
I, for one, am grateful and impressed. Long live Zoho!
Posted by: David Huston | October 1, 2008 10:51 PM