ReadWriteWeb

IT Consolidation Blues: CHOI Does Not Spell Choice

Written by Bernard Lunn / April 23, 2009 2:30 AM / 8 Comments

Oracle is buying Sun, and bankers are looking forward to the next wave of consolidation. To somebody who remembers the innovation and excitement of earlier enterprise hardware and software start-ups, this is a bit gloomy. CHOI (Cisco, HP, Oracle, IBM) does not spell "choice" for buyers, employees, or investors. Choose your behemoth. If consolidation means lower prices -- and it will -- buyers will be happy. But, it all sounds like cost-cutting, layoffs, and less innovation to me.

Parallel Universes

Meanwhile, in a parallel universe called cloud computing and SaaS, start-ups are starting and growing, innovation is happening at a staggering pace, and it all looks rather fun and fast-paced.

Are both types of companies living in the same universe? Clearly, they are. Could the boom on one side and gloom on the other be connected?

Is it possible that the cloud and SaaS are the backdrop to all this consolidation?

Very Large, Gloomy Eeyores

Back in October, we wrote about why some traditional enterprise IT vendors are selling the line that SaaS is a passing phase, that it is "old wine in a new bottle."

"There are people who really believe that SaaS is a passing fad, just Service Bureau 3.0. These people are like Eeyore, the old gray donkey from Winnie the Pooh. They think the Tigger types who are constantly running around excited about new technology are just, well ridiculous. There are others, like Piglet, who are just scared of anything new and big. The Wisdom Of Pooh, is just humbly asking questions.

"But the guys running large enterprise IT vendors are smart. They are just putting on the Eeyore act to appeal to Eeyore clients to keep buying the old stuff as long as possible."

Behemoths Selling to Behemoths

"Ah, but surely, mate, you understand that this stuff ain't enterprise-ready." That is what the enterprise veterans tell the SaaS startups. Well, at least they do until one accepts the offer from that fast-growing SaaS startup.

If you set the agenda as being whatever passes muster with the internal IT department, then yes, the CHOI behemoths will always win. But a much bigger wave of change is happening, a more radical wave, which we described in our post "Enterprise 2.0: The Nature of the Firm."

In this world, SaaS wins. The CHOI vendors know this. They are only pretending to be Eeyore. They are bulking up so that they can defend the declining part of their business while investing in the SaaS future.


Comments

Subscribe to comments for this post OR Subscribe to comments for all ReadWriteEnterprise posts

  1. I guess it's good for sun to be accquired by oracle.
    at least they get to keep the hardware apartment.

    Posted by: 布里斯班 | April 23, 2009 3:55 AM



  2. good services

    Posted by: sumit | April 23, 2009 4:16 AM



  3. i think its good that Oracle is buying Sun.

    Posted by: Full Tilt Poker Bonus Code | April 23, 2009 7:10 AM



  4. Bernard,

    I think innovation mostly comes from companies when they are small, eager and hunger to establish themselves. Once they become giants like Oracle, they just launch newer versions of the same products with small revisions.

    Posted by: RechargeYourMind | April 23, 2009 9:03 AM



  5. MySQL is currently open source :: I would think that this could be grown into its own, new open source system. Am I wrong? Does the license allow for it to fork?

     Posted by: Michael Author Profile Page | April 23, 2009 3:34 PM



  6. oh,It consolidation blues,may be IBM,sum or Misafort...Are both types of companies living in the same universe? Clearly, they are. Could the boom on one side and gloom on the other be connected?

    replica chopard watches

    replica breitling watches

    patek philippe replica watch

    Replica iwc watches

    Posted by: Alex | April 24, 2009 8:00 PM



  7. We are experiencing the industrialization of IT Services as Irving Wladawsky-Berger recently blogged about. SaaS is leading the way with the consumerization of IT services.


    http://bit.ly/jB12x

    Posted by: TJGodel | April 25, 2009 8:50 AM



  8. ow.. sun buying oracle? go open source

    Posted by: Rara | October 27, 2009 3:11 AM



Leave a comment

Optional: Sign in with Connect Facebook   Sign in with Twitter Twitter   Sign in with OpenID OpenID  |  
RWW SPONSORS