crowdsourcing - ReadWriteWeb http://www.readwriteweb.com/feeds/tag/crowdsourcing en Copyright 2012 Richard MacManus readwriteweb@gmail.com Tue, 14 Feb 2012 16:10:00 -0800 http://www.sixapart.com/movabletype/?v=4.35-en http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/tech/rss Google Maps Adds New Crowdsourced Maps of Afghanistan, Iraq & Elsewhere latlong_jun10.jpgGoogle has just announced the latest class of countries to graduate from Google Map Maker and become full-fledged citizens of Google Maps. Map Maker allows "citizen cartographers" to add details like little roads, businesses and geographic features to parts of the world that Google's staff can't easily reach.

Today's announcement incorporates community contributions from a bunch of new countries, territories, and even an entire continents into the live Google map. The graduates are: Afghanistan, Antarctica, Ecuador, Georgia, Guatemala, Heard Island and McDonald Islands, Honduras, Iraq, Norfolk Island, Saint Pierre & Miquelon and Saudi Arabia.

]]>
Kabul, Afghanistan before and after graduation
Kabul.png

Google has strained under the weight of mapping the entire wold. After launching Map Maker to crowdsource the effort in 2008, it has steadily increased the importance of community contributions. In April, Google opened Map Maker in the U.S., a tacit admission that it can't map all the locations and businesses itself, even in the world's most wired places.

In September, the Google LatLong team even shifted some of the Map Maker approval process onto Regional Expert Reviewers from the community, rather than having staff moderate all changes.

Time-lapse video of updates for Baghdad, Iraq

The system has shown signs of strain. It took the Google Maps team two months to recognize South Sudan's independence, despite a clamoring community. But Google has pressed forward with its effort to expand the global importance of Maps. In August, 40 new countries received localized top-level domains for Google Maps.

As curating Maps becomes a worldwide effort, crowd contributions from Map Maker will only become more important. Today's large crop of graduates is a recognition of great work by a community of volunteers around the world.

Time-lapse video of updates for Tblisi, Georgia

Congratulations to the graduates!

For more before-after photos and videos, check out the Google LatLong Blog.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_maps_adds_new_crowdsourced_maps_of_afghanis.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_maps_adds_new_crowdsourced_maps_of_afghanis.php Google Thu, 06 Oct 2011 11:15:00 -0800 Jon Mitchell
NYT Crowdsources the Review of 24,000 Palin Emails nytimesbutton_150x150.jpgTomorrow, the State of Alaska is set to release over 24,000 of Sarah Palin's emails, "covering much of her tenure as governor of Alaska." The New York Times is hoping that its readers will pitch in and help them filter this vast cache of new data on the former governor and erstwhile vice presidential candidate. Derek Willis announced the project on the Times's Caucus blog.

"We're asking readers to help us identify interesting and newsworthy e-mails, people and events that we may want to highlight. Interested users can fill out a simple form to describe the nature of the e-mail, and provide a name and e-mail address so we'll know who should get the credit. Join us here on Friday afternoon and into the weekend to participate."
]]> kuwait palin.jpgThe Times has a cadre of reporters in Alaska's capitol, Juneau. But the sheer amount of information and the perennial race to be first out with the story has inspired the news to lasso their readers into the process. The NYT has a robust relationship with the Web (including a syndication deal with ReadWriteWeb) and has a reasonably intelligent and engaged readership.

The release, which begins at 9:00 a.m. Alaska time (one hour earlier than Pacific Time) tomorrow, will consist of "e-mails Ms. Palin sent as governor, mostly using private accounts" and "are to be released in response to public records requests first made in 2008," according to the Times. The release is only being made in hard copy, which will fill "six standard paper boxes, a total of about 250 pounds at a printing cost of $725 per set."

Palin is currently on a bus trip across the country which reads as a thinly-disguised public relations event and temperature-taking for a possible run at the presidency. Even if she decides against running, her influence with the right-wing Tea Party movement makes her newsworthy. So what she my have thought and how she may have acted while in office as Alaska's governor will be of interest to many.

Other news organizations are also preparing processes to leverage the participation of their audience, including MSNBC, Mother Jones and ProPublica, who are working with Crivella West to create a publicly searchable database.

Palin photo by asecondhandconjecture

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/nyt_crowdsources_the_review_of_palin_emails.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/nyt_crowdsources_the_review_of_palin_emails.php Politics Thu, 09 Jun 2011 15:34:00 -0800 Curt Hopkins
Largest Telescope in the World to Rely on Crowdsourced Computing Power radio telescope.jpgThe largest telescope ever to exist (on this planet anyway) is going to be the Square Kilometre Array. The SKA will cost about $2.1 billion to construct. Australia and South Africa are bidding on the project. What may give Australia an edge is the way they intend to handle the massive computer processing and storage demands of the array. Crowdsourcing.

The crowdsourced computing initiative which those behind the Australia bid have put together will leverage personal computer power in lieu of extremely expensive petaflop supercomputers.

]]> ska.jpgArtist's rendition of the Square Kilometre Array

Computerworld Australia describes the crowdsourcing project.

"The International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), along with iVEC, the company running the $80 million high performance computing Pawsey Centre at CSIRO in Western Australia, are set to launch a 'citizen science' application this year based on the open source Nereus V Cloud computing technology developed at Oxford University. The application, dubbed "theskynet" by Australian researchers, would grant anyone not affiliated with the global telescope project access to the datasets formed out of the array's work."

By 2013, when it is fully up and running, the application should allow the Pawsey Centre to engage in petaflop computing. It will also make it the third-fastest supercomputer in the world, as well as possbily the largest cloud computing networks on the globe.

According to PopSci, the SKA will consist of 3,000 radio dishes, "spread as far as 2,000 miles in every direction from a central core, offering a full 1,000,000 square meters (that's one square kilometer) of collection surface."

There have been crowdsourcing projects already to help crunch the massive data that comes through various astronomical projects, most famously, the Seti@Home project, which began in 1999. Seti@Home is a radio telescope project to listen for signals that might come from intelligent life. It continues to this day.

Distributing computing and storage needs between institutional and personal computers is not a one-way street. In addition to saving money, saving heat and energy (using already-running computers), it will also provide datasets from the array to both scientists and members of the public willing to run the app on their rigs.

Australian radio telescope photo by Amanda Stater

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/largest_telescope_in_the_world_to_rely_on_crowdsou.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/largest_telescope_in_the_world_to_rely_on_crowdsou.php Science Mon, 30 May 2011 14:00:00 -0800 Curt Hopkins
Google Map Maker Comes to U.S. Maps globe 150x150Google Map Maker opened up to U.S. users today, allowing anyone to submit updates, revisions and additional information to the company's online mapping service. The tool was originally designed for users in other countries without access to the mapping resources we have stateside. Says Google, prior to the launch of Map Maker, only 15% of the world's population had detailed access to online maps of their neighborhoods, but now, citizen cartographers in 183 countries and regions have created maps of the places they live. Today, 30% of users people worldwide have access to online maps, thanks to Map Maker.

Given the extensive mapping services available here in the U.S., why would Google open up this tool here? Google is crowdsourcing corrections and additions, the company says, by allowing its users to add more detail about the places they know best. But there may be more to it than that.

]]> Map maker

With the Map Maker, Google says you can fix the name of local businesses or add improved descriptions. You can also add more information about an area, like bike lanes or the names of buildings on college campuses, for example. To prevent any high jinx from occurring, Google notes that it will review the user-created submissions before they go live.

While on the surface, the launch of Map Maker in the U.S. appears to just be another useful feature to differentiate Google's mapping service from its competitors, there may be some additional motives behind this launch.

One motive may have to do with the expansion of Google Places, the search company's Yelp-like business locator service. In April, Google merged its socially-infused local business recommendation service called Hotpot into Google Places, the larger business database which provides reviews and venue information. Now Google is crowdsourcing edits to that same database via this U.S. launch of Google Map Maker.

Building a Better Location Database, Thanks to You

One of the primary assets of companies involved in providing location-based services is their database of venues. On this front, Facebook is a tough Google competitor, with its own database of locations called Facebook Places. In September 2010, a company spokesperson said the goal for Facebook Places was to be the "central platform for location data" across the Web. And in February 2011, Facebook made some under-the-hood changes to the way it houses venues listed on its site, a move that enables the network to have an accurate, universally standardized database of locations.

Location-based check-in service Foursquare also has its own venue database, and, like Google will now as well, uses crowdsourcing to help keep that database accurate. In theory, select superusers on Foursquare's service are enlisted to clean up duplicate venues and make sure each pushpin is accurately placed. The job of crowdsourcing this cleanup is not going well in my local area - nearly every major venue has at least 2 or 3 clones, if not more. In fact, last I checked, my gym was listed four or five times!  (I'd love to hear more about your experience with this problem, or if you don't have one.) This may or may not be an across-the-board complaint, but it does highlight the challenges of creating a location database where users themselves are permitted to enter venues of their own, with no direct company oversight.

It should also be noted that another Google competitor, Microsoft's Bing, has also gone the crowdsourcing route to some extent, partnering with Open Street Map (OSM) back in August 2010, to make it available as an additional layer on top of Bing Maps. The company has donated aerial imagery to the Open Street Maps community too, and, in November, hired OSM founder Steve Coast to come work at Bing Maps.

To put it simply, today's announcement from Google has a deeper impact to the company's overall strategic initiatives than simply a case of "oh look, new tools!" Clean, accurate, robust, detailed and up-to-date maps and databases of locations will be key to growing any business that leverages location data in the future, which today includes a number of mobile services, and their online counterparts.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_map_maker_comes_to_the_US.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_map_maker_comes_to_the_US.php Google Tue, 19 Apr 2011 08:23:49 -0800 Sarah Perez
Chirply Crowdsources Greeting Card Designs, A Threadless for Stationery chirply150.jpgHallmark spends some $60 million a year on designs for its greeting cards, and yet - with apologies to those artists - it can still be quite a challenge to find the just the right card. Frankly, a lot of cards are ugly. They're tacky. They're sappy.

So Y Combinator alum Chirply is taking on the greeting card industry by crowdsourcing stationery designs. Chirply had its soft launch a few weeks ago, soliciting designs and voting, and the startup is now ready to open its doors to the retail business.

]]> Crowdsourcing has become a popular alternative to the pre-packaged imagery that appears on clothing, with companies like Threadless offering crowdsourced designs on t-shirts and clothing. Chirply works in a similar fashion: designers submit their images. Visitors to the site get to vote on submissions. And the most popular designs become products for sale.

chirplyss1.jpgChirply's greeting card cost $4 (with shipping included in the U.S.) and users can buy any 10 designs in a mix-and-match pack for $25. The cards are all 100% recucled, 100% post-consumer waste. In addition to greeting cards, Chirply also offers the designs printed on notebooks and on wrapping paper.

This is great news for consumers (because, come on, we are socially obligated to buy greeting cards and we spend an inordinate amount of time sighing at the selection). But more importantly, Chirply is great news for designers.

Co-founders Gagan and Neel Palrecha care a lot about the design community, and they want to insure not only that the Chirply has beautiful designs for consumers to vote on and purchase, but that designers can participate in a site that showcases their work and compensates them fairly. Chirply doesn't ask designers to submit their original files, for example, just composites (until their submissions are voted on to be printed, of course). And Chirply pays artists a flat fee ($300) up front when their designs are selected, in addition to paying royalties based on sales.

Since Chirply's soft launch, this approach does seem to be working, as the startup has attracted some high quality submissions. That has piqued visitors interest, who on average cast about 30 votes, often over multiple sessions. The top cards on the sites have received well over 500 votes, in just under 5 weeks.

chirplyss.jpg

In addition to opening its retail store today, Chirply is announcing a round of funding, from a lost list of investors including Keith Rabois, Dave McClure, Mitch Kapor, Charles River Ventures, and others.

An added bonus: ReadWriteWeb readers can get 30% off their orders if they use the code "RWW" during checkout.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/chirply_crowdsources_greeting_card_designs_a_threa.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/chirply_crowdsources_greeting_card_designs_a_threa.php Art Thu, 07 Apr 2011 11:00:00 -0800 Audrey Watters
CNN Announces iReport Awards for Participatory Journalism

If you're a TV actor, you have the Emmy Awards. If you're a journalist, you have the Pulitzer Prize. But if you're a citizen reporter, what do you have? Nothing, until now.

CNN announced today that it was launching the CNN iReport Awards "to honor the best examples of participatory journalism in 2010."

]]> CNN first launched the user-generated iReport feature nearly five years ago and last year alone users contributed more than 150,000 "iReports". The project surpassed more than 740,000 "iReporters" in 2010. How does it work? Users submit reports to CNN directly on the Web or from the iPhone app, which are posted to the iReport section of CNN.com.

"The collaborative relationship that we have with our iReporters is one of the unique strengths of CNN, and in many ways represents the future of storytelling," said Meredith Artley, managing editor and vice president of CNN.com, in a press release. "These awards are designed to celebrate those outstanding efforts."

According to the release, awards will be broken up into six categories: Breaking News, Original Reporting, Compelling Imagery (photos or video), Commentary, Personal Story, and Interview. In each category, five users have been nominated and will be judged by a panel of "innovators and trailblazers in participatory storytelling."

ireports-screenshot.JPG

Nominees run the gamut, from iReporter Johnny Colt, who "took a boat out to the coast of Grand Island in Louisiana to expose BP for its slow effort in cleaning up the oil spill", to Sam Bolton, who "investigated the lack of progress made to clean up unexploded bomblets from the Vietnam War." While all of these iReporters may have varying levels of training and experience, they have something in common - the desire to relate their experiences and stories to the world, and CNN offers that platform. Of course, anyone could simply upload videos or relate these accounts on Twitter, Facebook, Blogger or any other "Web 2.0" medium, but CNN might lend a bit of credibility. When CNN independently confirms details on a report, it stamps it with a "vetted" badge.

Awards will close on March 7, but until then you can see all 30 nominees on the iReport Awards site.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/cnn_announces_ireport_awards_for_participatory_jou.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/cnn_announces_ireport_awards_for_participatory_jou.php Crowdsourcing Tue, 15 Feb 2011 18:18:01 -0800 Mike Melanson
Twitter Opens Translation Center to Crowdsource Its Move Into New Languages twitter_bird150150.pngThe events in Egypt over the past few weeks have highlighted the important role that Twitter is taking in communicating and coordinating events of global significance. Indeed, over 70% of Twitter users come from outside the United States. And while English has been the service's dominant language, the company does offer Twitter in six other languages: French, German, Italian, Japanese, Korean and Spanish.

In order to help make Twitter more accessible to this growing global user-base, the company has just announced the Twitter Translation Center, an effort to crowdsource translations so that Twitter can quickly launch in additional languages.

]]> The efforts won't be aimed at translating tweets, but rather at translating the product itself. (You can see the difference if you go to your settings page and change your language.)

New languages added to the Translation Center, in addition to those already offered, include Indonesian, Russian and Turkish. Those are the languages into which Twitter will be translated next, and the company says there are more to come.

Crowdsourced Translations

Crowdsourcing translations isn't new. Facebook is now available in over 70 languages, for example, thanks in part to the efforts of over 300,000 users who helped translate the site. And Twitter says it's been using volunteer translators since October 2009.

Crowdsourcing translation works by taking a word or phrase - such as "hashtag" or "Privacy Policy" - and asking for input and feedback on translations. The community then agrees on the best possible translation. You can sign up to help translate Twitter - its mobile and websites, its apps, its help and business centers.

translationss2.jpg

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/twitter_opens_translation_center_to_crowdsource_it.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/twitter_opens_translation_center_to_crowdsource_it.php Twitter Mon, 14 Feb 2011 09:43:32 -0800 Audrey Watters
LearnBoost Crowdsources Its Translation, Open Sources Its Node.js Internationalization learnboost_logo_dec10.pngFree online gradebook LearnBoost has announced its plans to crowdsource translation of its app. The decision makes sense as the startup's gradebook has already been adopted by teachers in schools in over 20 countries, and many have requested native language support. "Our product's engagement levels have been through the roof," says co-founder Thianh Lu, "but we knew that this approach would work when we received countless emails from users preemptively offering to translate our product for free."

]]> Following Facebook's Lead: Crowdsourcing Translation

LearnBoost's decision to crowdsource the translation echoes the process that Facebook started two years ago, something that proved incredibly successful in helping the social network spread internationally. Facebook is now available in over 70 languages, thanks to the 300,000 or so users that helped translate the site. LearnBoost is hoping that taking a similar approach will give them a cost-effective way to boost their international audience as well.

But with a far smaller engineering team and a far smaller user-base, LearnBoost has developed a technological solution that's "better than Facebook's," boasts CEO and co-founder Rafael Corrales. This is in no small part because translators will never have to see or understand the HTML tags that often appear in other crowdsourced translation efforts.

learnboost_translate_ss.pngLearnBoost has created an active translation interface, showing teachers which phrases need to be translated, as well as where it is located in the application in order to provide some context. Submitted phrases are compared and vetted by an internal tool for accuracy, and the community can vote on the most popular phrases.

Once a language has been translated, users will be able to view LearnBoost's gradebook in their native language. And because of the way in which LearnBoost has built the tool, as new features and pages roll out, LearnBoost's system will automatically include them in the crowdsourcing translation process. In other words, the translation feature will scale as LearnBoost grows.

Open Sourcing Translation, Internationalizing Node.JS

And while a translation project to spread LearnBoost to non-English-speaking educators is cool, as with many of LearnBoost's undertakings, what's under the hood is just as exciting. LearnBoost has built an internationalization layer on top of the Jade node.js template language that, in the words of co-founder and CTO Guillermo Rauch, "makes it easy for developers to define what needs to be translated. Traditionally, developers have to be bothered to add translation hooks that are too obtrusive and have to deal with HTML, which in turns is difficult for translators." In addition, with the help of a tool called jade-serial, every time a new feature (and by extension a new phrase) is added, the internationalization systems checks to see if requires a translation.

For very young and small company, LearnBoost has open sourced a number of impressive open source projects, and the startup already has over 2500 followers on GitHub. And this new translation tool, jade-i18n, is available alongside LearnBoost's other projects, including Socket.IO and Mongoose.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/learnboost_crowdsources_its_translation_open_sourc.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/learnboost_crowdsources_its_translation_open_sourc.php E-Learning Mon, 13 Dec 2010 12:15:54 -0800 Audrey Watters
Amazon.com Launches Movie Studio amazon-logo.pngThe world's largest Internet retailer Amazon.com is known for many things besides shopping - Kindle eBook readers, for example, or its cloud computing infrastructure known as Amazon Web Services - but Amazon as a movie studio? That one seemed to come out of left field, didn't it?

Well, it's true - kind of. Amazon is indeed getting into the movie-making business with the launch of a new portal called Amazon Studios, but it's not a traditional studio by any means.

]]> Instead, Amazon's latest venture invites independent filmmakers and screenwriters to submit their content to the site in order to get discovered and possibly even have their movie made by Warner Bros., the "real" studio behind the project.

Crowdsourced Movie Production

The Amazon Studios portal provides tools that allow anyone to upload their content, be it a script or a full-length movie called a "test movie." These "test movies" have to be more than 70 minutes, but don't have to be "full budget," explains the company.

Once online, other Amazon members can read the scripts, watch the movies and even edit the content, by uploading their own alternate or revised versions. Members can also provide general feedback on the items uploaded to the site.

Amazon Studios will also award cash prizes in regular contests to those with the best scripts or movies. The first contest, underway now, is offering $100,000 for the best movie and two $20,000 awards for the best script. (Details here). In 2011, Amazon will dole out $1.1 million in awards, with $1,000,000 for the best movie and $100,000 for the best script. (Details here).

Winners are selected by a judging committee, an unknown group of "experts" and company execs, who will determine which items are worthy of Warner Bros.' attention.

amazon_studios_site-1.jpg

Warner Bros., as the only Hollywood studio partnered with Amazon, has a "first look" deal with the new site, meaning Amazon Studio winners will be considered for future theatrical feature films. In addition to the cash rewards, winners actually get to meet with Warner Bros. development executives.

Said Roy Price, director of digital product development for Amazon, the company hopes that the new site will help filmmakers experiment and collaborate with each other. Filmmakers can make movies with the scripts posted online, for example, while screenwriters can upload scripts to get their movies made.

Internet Community & Movie-Making: Sometimes You Get "Snakes on a Plane"

The goal of the project is to "democratize" the process of breaking into Hollywood - and for that, we (and anyone who's seen some of the drivel that keeps getting produced there) are grateful. That being said, the Internet community doesn't always have the best judgement when it comes to what makes a great movie. Let's not forget the "Snakes on a Plane" debacle of 2006. Probably one of the first cases of crowdsourcing movie production to fans, filmmakers even reshot parts of the movie in response to fan feedback: they added more snakes, more gore, more death scenes and even the now infamous line, " I want these mother..... snakes off the mother.... plane!"

Of course, the movie bombed. It made just $1 million more than its production budget alone. What works online doesn't always translate to the big screen, you see.

Granted, in that case, there wasn't a "test movie" involved, like the kind Amazon is proposing - fans at the time were reacting to what they knew of the film's plot. Seeing a low-budget version of the film online may have changed things - it's hard to say. After all, the Internet community has an odd sense of humor at times.

As for whether the new Studios project is an oddball offering for Amazon, a site primarily thought of as a shopping portal, it's not, really. For one thing, the end product Amazon is funding will end up as inventory on its virtual shelves. Amazon also has a history of "democratizing" access through Internet technology. Its cloud computing infrastructure delivers the power of large server farms to even the smallest business or individual and its lesser-known, but fairly popular, on-demand, scalable workforce at Mechanical Turk crowdsources large jobs by splitting them up into smaller tasks performed by anyone with an Internet connection and a bit of time to kill online.

Amazon Studios fits in nicely with those types of democratizing, crowdsourced ventures. Whether or not it will lead to the next major blockbuster, however, is yet to be seen.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/amazon_launches_movie_studio.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/amazon_launches_movie_studio.php Amazon Wed, 17 Nov 2010 08:18:52 -0800 Sarah Perez
Google Invests $4.25M in Crowdsourced Online Ad Marketplace Trada googletrada_jul10.jpgBack in May, we mentioned that Boulder startup Trada - a crowdsourced solution for creating keyword-based pay-per-click (PPC) ad campaigns - had introduced support for Microsoft's Bing search engine. Today, Trada is getting a huge leg-up from Bing's competition as Google Ventures has invested over $4 million, leading the company's latest round of funding. Joining Google in the Series C round is Foundry Group, whose $1.5M investment mark's the Bouler firms third investment with Trada.

]]> "We're really happy to have another significant venture firm taking a position in the crowdsourcing ecosystem."
- Neil RobertsonTrada allows small businesses and large ad agencies to run search marketing campaigns across Google, Yahoo! and Bing with the help of the company's rapidly expanding community of paid search experts. Trada now boasts over 500 total search experts, and says another 300 are on a waiting list to participate. Over 200 business and agencies currently use trada, 55 of which signed up just last month. Of those that joined in June, a full quarter came from large ad agencies.

"We're growing very quickly and we're very happy with the uptake," Trada founder and CEO Neil Robertson told ReadWriteWeb. "Google Ventures looked at our businesses and the assessment was that our growth was interesting to them."

New Cash, New Goals

globe2_jul10.jpgThe $5.75 million C round brings Trada's total fundraising to just under $8 million. Robertson says the company has been extremely tight budgeted thus far, spending just $2 million over the last two years. The sudden influx of cash will give the company breathing room to expand and try some new things, he says.

First, the company plans to help provide improved and tailored services to both its large agency customers and its smaller business customers. Secondly, it will expand internationally to run campaigns in more countries. Currently, Trada accepts international customers and experts in the U.K., Australia and Canada, but has yet to brand out to non-English speaking countries.

Lastly, as part of the company's long-term goals, Trada is looking to extend its crowdsourced PPC ad model to other forms of online advertisements. Robertson says the company started with PPC ads because of the obvious crowdsourcing benefits to keyword campaigns. Now the company realizes that other ad styles - including display, banner, mobile and video ads - can also work on this model. The company also expects to allow for campaigns on newer ad platforms, like Facebook and Twitter in the near future.

The Google Bump

levineminer_jul10.jpgGoogle piece of the funding comes from Google Ventures, the company's investment arm. Rich Miner, one of the original co-founders of Android, has been on boards with Robertson in the past and now manages the Google Ventures fund. Miner joins Robertson and Foundry Group's Seth Levine as members of Trada's board.

While the connection between Google and Trada is an easy one to make, Robertson says that not preferential treatment is given to any of the search giant's investments. As Robertson added, Google likes to make sure that "all boats rise with the tide" when it comes to its investments. The relationship will also not affect or limit the services which Trada offers to its customers, said Robertson.

The fresh cash certainly puts a smile on the faces at Trada, but out of everything, Robertson is most excited for the crowdsourcing community at large.

"We're really happy to have another significant venture firm taking a position in the crowdsourcing ecosystem," said Robertson, who heads an information group of similar companies known as the Crowdsortium. "It's a good sign to see larger tech companies in the evolution of this industry."

Photo by Flickr user horiavalan.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_invests_crowdsourced_online_ad_marketplace_trada.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/google_invests_crowdsourced_online_ad_marketplace_trada.php Google Wed, 21 Jul 2010 07:30:00 -0800 Chris Cameron
With Debut of Web Apps Q&A Site, Stack Exchange Perfects Automated Site Launch Process A site called "Web Applications" (beta) is the newest addition to the Stack Exchange network, a service that powers popular tech Q&A sites including StackOverflow, ServerFault, SuperUser.com and StackApps. Like the others before it, the new site uses the same back-end framework to create a simple user interface where people can post questions and answers, this time about Web applications. For example: How do you export mail from Gmail? Or delete your Facebook account? Or send giant files via email?

But "Web Applications" is just the first of many new StackOverflow-like sites on the horizon, and surprisingly, the next sites to launch may not be tech-focused at all. ]]> Stack Exchange Uses Crowd-Sourcing to Launch New Sites

StackOverflow, the original site that led to the Stack Exchange network's creation was founded by Joel Spolsky, author and CEO of bug-tracking software company Fog Creek Software, and respected developer Jeff Atwood back in 2008. The idea was to create an alternative to the market leader at the time, Experts-Exchange (EE). Where EE was a fee-based site, the vision for StackOverflow was to offer a simpler, entirely free site where you could get the same type of assistance from knowledgeable users. To encourage participation, site users vote up the best answers to questions and those whose answers are voted on receive boosts in their "reputation" scores.

Earlier this year, the company raised $6 million from Union Square Ventures and announced plans to launch a handful of targeted sites running the same software. Spolsky said that the future sites would be determined by an automated process where community members propose a site, establish the site's ground rules and gather a team of core experts who commit to the site. When a critical mass has been built up (the boiling point determined by algorithms alone), the site opens. You can see this process in action now in StackExchange's new staging area, dubbed "Area51." Here, you can track the proposed sites, how many people have committed to them, details about the site's plans and goals, and, once launched, stats on number of users, questions, answers, views and more.

Web Applications, the Q&A site for "expert and advanced users of Web applications" was the first site to go through this automated launch process and a site for "Gaming" is now hot on its heels.

While the newest addition to the network is certainly a handy resource (we already learned how to print a Google Wave and organize Gmail labels), it's the site staging area that's the most impressive part of this whole venture. Instead of the company having to think up ideas, gather interest, entice experts to sign up and encourage people to join, the entire process has been offloaded to the community itself to handle. It's crowd-sourcing at its best.

Beyond Tech: StackOverflow's for Cooking, Guitar and Grammar?

The site staging area will allow Stack Exchange to extend beyond its tech roots, assuming the future proposals in Area51 prove popular enough to reach the launch stage. Sites for food and cooking, English language and its usage, home improvement, photography, board games, coffee, guitars and other less-technical hobbies are listed among the geekier topics like SEO, game development, GIS, user interface design, healthcare IT and more.

The question now is how will these niche Stack Exchange sites compete with the one-stop shops, like the recently launched Question and Answer service Quora, which provides a single destination to ask questions about anything? Or the more personal Q&A offering from Formspring, which lets individuals share answers with a community on conversational topics. Plus, we can't ignore the fact that Facebook, too, is planning a Q&A app called "Questions." Can anything complete when Facebook - and its nearly half a billion users - get involved? And will Stack Exchange's niche answers fare as well as Yahoo Answers when it comes to being highly ranked by Google's algorithms?

Stack Exchange's move from a tech-related resource to a network of sites with broader appeal is a smart move, given the interest in the question-and-answer space at this time. But it also opens it up to bigger competition as well. It was one thing to take down Experts Exchange, but can it do the same with Facebook and Yahoo?

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/with_debut_of_web_apps_qa_site_stack_exchange_perfects_automated_site_launch_process.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/with_debut_of_web_apps_qa_site_stack_exchange_perfects_automated_site_launch_process.php Product Reviews Thu, 08 Jul 2010 07:11:31 -0800 Sarah Perez
Crowdsourcing Goes Hollywood with YouTube's 'Life in a Day' Project lifeinaday_jul10.jpgOne of the most impressive benefits of the real-time Web is its ability to allow people to instantly collaborate on massive global projects from the comfort of their own home. Between editing articles on Wikipedia and helping rescuers locate evidence of a downed aircraft in dense woodland areas, there is no shortage of ways to collaborate on the Web. It is in this spirit of crowdsourcing that YouTube is launching a new project, "Life in a Day," which it hopes will tell the story of a single day on Earth.

]]> Working with sponsor LG Electronics and film directors Ridley Scott and Kevin Macdonald, YouTube is asking users to take a moment out their days on July 24th to document something that shows their perspective of the world on that day. "You can film the ordinary -- a sunrise, the commute to work, a neighborhood soccer match, or the extraordinary -- a baby's first steps, your reaction to the passing of a loved one, or even a marriage," says YouTube's product marketing manager, Tim Partridge.

The bits and pieces submitted from around the world will then be collected and built into a feature-length documentary film that will debut at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival in Utah. Anyone whose footage makes it into the film will be credited as a co-director and could also be one of 20 people selected to attend the premier.

This project has enormous potential to create something truly amazing, in my opinion. YouTube is by far the largest resource for sharing and viewing video on the Web, and big name directors Scott and Macdonald should have no problem creating a compelling story from the plethora of submissions they are likely to receive.

Other projects in the past have leveraged the YouTube community to create collaborative media projects. Composer Eric Whitacre assembled a virtual "YouTube Choir" by taking submissions from users singing the various voices of a few of his choral pieces. The success of YouTube's "Life in a Day" project could be big win for crowdsourcing and the real-time Web, placing it front-and-center in the spotlight and encouraging its further evolution as a platform for multimedia collaboration.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/crowdsourcing_goes_hollywood_with_youtubes_life_in_a_day_project.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/crowdsourcing_goes_hollywood_with_youtubes_life_in_a_day_project.php YouTube Wed, 07 Jul 2010 09:22:00 -0800 Chris Cameron
1 Million Entries Later, crowdSPRING Still Going Strong Though it draws divided opinions from the design community, crowdsourced creative services market crowdSPRING has maintained a sizable user base of designers and writers. The site allows users to submit entries for sponsored competitions of creative tasks, such as logo and website design, or copywriting. Today the site announced the passing of a significant milestone in its two-year history as over one million user entries have been submitted to the site.

]]> crowdspring_stuff_jul10.jpgSince opening in May 2008, crowdSPRING, home to roughly 65,000 users from 175 countries, has hosted over 12,000 project contests, averaging over 116 entries per project, the company says. Small businesses and organizations can log into the site and submit a proposal for the creative work they need done. They can ask for a logo design, a web page design (with or without code writing), business card and letterhead design, or even written tasks like site copy or just ideas for names of products.

The project managers choose a reward price for their copmany's project, the minimum being $200, and users submit their entries for consideration. The managers can then interact with the users, offering suggestions for revisions, and eventually hand pick a winner to receive the reward in return for the already completed work.

Large corporations have even joined in the action, offering large rewards for projects like designing a new pasta shape for Barilla, or creating a new iteration of TiVo's logo. But reactions to crowdSPRING's methods have not been all smiles.

forrst_guy_jul10.jpgMany take offense to the fact that users are asked to submit fully completed creative works to the site without any guarantee of compensation - a practice some refer to as "spec work." We investigated this issue back in January, and brought it up again in March after the site launched the addition of writing services and some were concerned about intellectual property.

Businesses that are concerned with the issues some raise about crowdSPRING show be aware of the alternatives available for sourcing creative services on the web. TechStars' Andrew Hyde, who is outspokenly against spec work and crowdSPRING, launched his own platform, Pick.im, which provides designers and developers (among others) with a place to host their portfolios and find work. Other sites, like Forrst, provide an exclusive community for designers and developers to interact and share work and get feedback.

Regardless of these other networks and the anti spec work sentiments, crowdSPRING has continued to grow as one million entries attest to the site's success.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/crowdspring_surpasses_1_million_creative_entries.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/crowdspring_surpasses_1_million_creative_entries.php Crowdsourcing Tue, 06 Jul 2010 14:30:00 -0800 Chris Cameron
New York Times Juices Up Its Document Viewer typewriterThe New York Times' new Doc Viewer 2.0 is, depending on what you value, either a pasted-on ornament of no real use to a typical news consumer, or it's an open-source, crowd-sourcing game changer.

With information-taming technologies like search engines already at a reader's fingertips, there is debatable value in the Doc Viewer's ability to annotate a story with "raw" information. However, the fact that the Doc Viewer's code is due to be released on an open-source basis introduces an additional value to it. It is not just the back-end that a media source, of whatever size, will have access to, but the whole megillah.

]]> Want annotated source materials embedded in your kitty blog without having to churn code until the tears flow? You can do it.

This latest viewer by the New York Times is the latest iteration of a two year development process. The viewer allows reporters to augment stories by including evidentiary documentation and providing context to news stories. The viewer keys documents to words or phrases in the source story, allowing viewers to pursue the process to the depth they prefer. These "annotations" are similar to an old-fashioned "hot link" but with a new-fangled dynamic delivery.

Future versions will open up the annotation process to readers, instead of just the writers and editors. Additional features may include an embeddable version for blogs, a search-friendly version without JavaScript, variable image file type control and the ability to create custom annotation shapes. The open-source software behind Version 2.0 will be released "in the very, very near future," according to the newspaper, and will be available on the Times' Github page.

The key criticism to this undertaking, of course, is: so what?

BayNewswer quoted Aron Pilhofer, the paper's editor for interactive newsroom technologies, as "recognizing that news organizations are slowly but gradually becoming more and more like technology companies." They are, that is, more likely to triumph if they leverage a wider distribution of invested community members.

Alan McLean, interface engineer at the Times, says his focus is on the Doc Viewer as a reporting tool.

"Fundamentally what we are trying to do here is get as many tools in the belts of reporters as we can to assist them in telling stories online," he told RWW. "Seeing it as a publishing platform is somewhat limited. It really depends on the kind of content that is being published."

However, Chris Heisel, in a post on an earlier version of this viewer, said, "In a world where I can easily find more infor­ma­tion than I can ever pos­si­bly use does the public really need more access to raw infor­ma­tion."

We read news in a politically and socially polarized environment. The most common charge against the NY Times - this most mainstream of MSM - is bias, that there is nothing more than a writer's unexamined feelings or political secret sauce to support the angle of a given story. With foundational documents appended to the story itself, the reasonableness of the reporter's approach should prove easier to determine.

But that is posited on the not-altogether-likely notion that reason and reality will overpower the desire to froth.

The New York Times is a syndication partner of ReadWriteWeb.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/new_york_times_juices_up_their_document_viewer.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/new_york_times_juices_up_their_document_viewer.php New Media Wed, 31 Mar 2010 16:00:00 -0800 Curt Hopkins
Will AOL Use Seed to Fuel Its Hyperlocal News Site? AOL-logo.jpgAOL is continuing with its push to create content on a massive local scale, according to a story by the Silicon Valley Insider. The story says that AOL is looking to "expand Patch, its network of local news blogs, from 30 sites to 'hundreds', by the end of 2010."

AOL recently announced a similar 0-to-60 sort of initiative with its attempt to cover every single band at this year's South By Southwest festival with its content distribution project Seed.

]]> The article quotes an internal communication, saying that AOL is looking "to be leaders in one of the most promising 'white spaces' on the Internet" as well as "in sourcing, creating, producing and delivering high quality content".

Patch is a "hyperlocal" website that offers news, photos and videos, discussions and information about local businesses. It is run by "professional editors, writers, photographers and videographers who live in or near the communities [they] serve". As such, Patch seems like a perfect candidate for the type of service offered by another arm of AOL, crowdsourced content provider Seed.

While the article declares the intention to go from 30 sites to hundreds "quite the ambitious goal," we wonder if having a system like Seed already in place wouldn't make an otherwise potentially daunting task a bit easier. Actually, the SXSW coverage seems like a good testing ground for doing the same sort of coverage in hundreds of locations throughout the country.

As Paid Content wrote last month, Saul Hansell left the New York Times' Bits Blog in December to join Seed, with the purpose of "leveraging Seed across all of AOL's platforms".

Looking at the site, it would seem that the only issue in growing from 30 to hundreds would be general scalability, as each location is identical, but with different content. With an army of content providers at your fingertips, it would seem that the expansion is the obvious next step more than anything else.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/the_new_aol_local_reporters_covering_your_neighbor.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/the_new_aol_local_reporters_covering_your_neighbor.php News Wed, 17 Feb 2010 11:23:00 -0800 Mike Melanson