hoax - ReadWriteWeb http://www.readwriteweb.com/feeds/tag/hoax en Copyright 2012 Richard MacManus readwriteweb@gmail.com Mon, 13 Feb 2012 17:00:00 -0800 http://www.sixapart.com/movabletype/?v=4.35-en http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/tech/rss RFID Hoaxes and Hexes The human capacity to find hidden meanings in things has given us poetry, physics and software. It's also given us superstitions, conspiracy theories and hoaxes. Given that this capacity is enduring it shouldn't come as any surprise that each new thing that comes along is inflected by it, and that includes technologies.

RFID is radio frequency identification. It's setting a small transmitter at a certain frequency, setting a reader to recognize that frequency. That's it. The implications as we have outlined, can include tracking wine inventory and sushi freshness. But there are other implications, ones rooted in, say, less demonstrable realities. RFID, to some, is the number of the beast.

]]> Cattle Rustling, RFID & The End Times

When we wrote the first article on the possible use of RFID as a way to stop an increase in cattle rustling, it was, predictably, not the most wildly popular of our posts. No Facebook connection, for one thing. But suddenly, it shot up in page views. We researched it and found out that our post had made its way onto a website that featured a news feed for those who are certain the world is about to end. We could not figure out why. Then it dawned on us. Between the red heifer some believe will usher in the Apocalypse, and the assignment of numbers to human subjects of the anti-Christ, we were good to go.

The flaw in the logic that assigns a particular evil to a particular technology is that any technology can be rendered into numbers. Anything from language to music to a printing press to a computer can be assigned numbers or produce them. I wouldn't bad-mouth anyone's religious expectations, but it's straight out syllogism to presume they are dependent on the technologies that just happened to be of recent vintage. Plus, just a sample of the different recent technologies that have been assigned an apocalyptic role in addition to RFID include magnetic strips, barcodes, computer chips and biochips.

Three RFID Hoaxes

Money Replaced With Implanted Chips. This refers again to the fears behind Christian teleology. Biochips were going to take the place of money. The chips were to be planted in the body. This is close in approach to the idea of paying with your smart phone. The only problem is that it's not true. The giveaway is the fact that those who "revealed" this plan manage to confuse and conflate biochips, RFID and magnetic cards.

The U.S. Government Tracks Homeless with Chips>. If the fact that it was an April Fool's joke to the Politech mailing list weren't enough, the fact that it was supposedly Health and Human Services behind this that should have been.

idsniper_function.jpgPolice Will Use RFID Rifles to Tag Dissidents. An artist, Jakob S Boeskov, cobbled together a convincing-looking rifle and toted it to an Chinese arms and armament conference, describing it as a way to non-lethally and permanently tag any trouble-makers in a mob situation. Practically everyone bought it. It turns out it was a "Fictionism" art event. Why was it accepted? The gun looked cool. It was performed in a context where such a thing might be valued. It was reported on by journalists looking for an angle - this was certainly one.

The reasons these tech hoaxes found a purchase on our imagination

First, the people who reported them, whether professional journalists or not, either wanted to believe them or didn't do due diligence in researching them. Second, professional journalists do not always explore and explain complex technologies as well as they should. For one thing, often times, we are excited about them and that can cloud the need to delve into their implications. For another, this stuff is hard. It can be hard for us to get our heads around, much less yours. (Neither of the foregoing are excuses, by the way. If anything, they are self-indictments.)

Second, this is an extremely complex era, in which changes in technology are matched by changes, challenges and crises in politics and environment. Even if it is not approaching a "singularity," it all seems to be getting faster almost exponentially. This drives people to seek explanations. When we fail at expressing the nature and limitations of technology as technology journalists, others fall in to breach the gap. Sometimes they do an excellent job. Sometimes they make a mess.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/rfid_hoaxes_and_hexes.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/rfid_hoaxes_and_hexes.php Internet of Things Fri, 04 Jun 2010 14:00:00 -0800 Curt Hopkins
Facebook Status Messages are the New Chain Emails "This status is being tracked. The owners of Facebook have confirmed they will send $1 to the rescue fund for Haiti every time this is cut and paste as a status." Sound familiar? This recent status message hoax has been making its way around the popular social network, duping members into posting the status as their own in the hopes that, by doing so, they've somehow contributed to the Haitian earthquake disaster relief fund without having to actually open their own pocketbook to do so. While that would be nice if it was true, this hoax is just one of many found on Facebook today.

]]> The hoodwinks, urban legends, fairy tales, humorous tall tales, and out-and-out scams that once arrived via our email inboxes have been slowly making their way to the world's largest social network. And as before, people are being fooled into reposting because the message always comes from a trusted friend.

Just like the emails that once promised free money from Bill Gates for participation in a Microsoft email beta test, reposting a Facebook status isn't going to produce money from thin air anymore than forwarding a chain email message would have done in years past. And yet, the same people who are now savvy enough to junk the email forwards and scams into their Deleted Items folder are blindly reposting status messages such as these as if they're the gospel truth.

Folks, urban legends have evolved. Status messages are the new chain email.

Urban legends have filled our inboxes for years on end. Before the days of technology, these same stories were idly passed around via chats at the water cooler and over-the-fencepost gossip sessions with fellow neighbors. It's said that the tales tap into a society's dark underbelly by posing as cautionary tales about the dangerous world we live in (AIDS from a gas pump! A hook-handed murderer!), or they simply tap into our deepest hopes and dreams. (You can get rich quick! You just have to forward an email!). Legends like these may change over the years, but they will always be around in some form or another and they won't be disappearing any time soon.

Watch Out, You're Being Spied On!

Another recent message making the rounds warns of something called "Unnamed app," a vicious little bot that supposedly slowlys down Facebook while also spying on your activities. While there is some truth to the fact that Facebook applications have an unworldly amount of access to your personal data, this particular app is not a rogue spybot secretly tracking your moves, it's just your everyday, run-of-the-mill software bug. And Facebook fixed it. But that probably won't stop thousands from "helpfully" passing this message onto their Facebook friends for days (if not weeks and months) to come.

Image Credit: sophos.com

Your Account Will be Deleted Unless...

These viral status messages, brand-new creations about Internet dangers and free money, aren't the only hoaxes to find their way to the social space. Older urban legends have also been re-crafted to now fit the Facebook era. Take, for example, the warning passed around in the early 2000's regarding the "overload" of people signing up for Hotmail accounts. According to this missive, Hotmail was over capacity and Microsoft needed to dump some people from the system. In order to prove you were still an active user, you were asked to forward the email to every Hotmail contact you had so that your account would not be deleted. Essentially a harmless prank, this warning transformed itself over the years, reappearing in various forms that threatened the accounts of Yahoo, then AOL, Friendster, Orkut, Bebo, and MySpace users alike. Today, that message is again being circulated as a Facebook status update. The new lingo? It's not "please forward" anymore - it's "Copy+Paste." Because if you don't, you know, your Facebook account will be deleted. Yikes!

In this case, the fear of losing Facebook access has led many users to repost the warning on their own walls, where it's seen by friends who pick it up and pass it around too. But again, there's no truth to this message either.

An Urban Legend or a Deeper Truth?

While the above hoax speaks greatly to our society's increased reliance on technology, how strong those ties are and how fearful we are of being without them, others play on even deeper emotions. The Facebook story about the $1-at-a-time donations might not be true (side note: the company has set up a Disaster Relief page for those interested in legitimate ways to help), there's a photo of a Haitian cross whose existence is harder to prove or disprove. Circulating via Facebook right now is this photo of a stone crucifix still left standing in the wake of the utter destruction that was the Haitian earthquake. That one's real, right? Well, maybe so, maybe not. Ever since the creation of Photoshop, answering questions like these have gotten much harder. What matters though, is not the photo's veracity (or lack thereof), but the fact that, to some, it seems to hold a deeper meaning about the nature of God - how he's still there even in times like these. For Christians, it's an image of hope in a world of suffering. And by reposting it time and again via Facebook, it's spreading virally around the globe.

It's precisely these emotions - our fears, our hopes, our desires - that urban legends tap into. And while some are more harmless than others, it can be difficult to know the difference between the truth and a false claim, as this above example clearly shows.

Think Before You Post

So what can you do? Although we're no longer deluged by the well-meaning warnings and fables that arrive via our email inboxes, we're still being subjected to their far-out claims. It's just that the medium is different. Once again, it's time to be vigilant. Just because you saw it on Facebook, that doesn't make it true. Just because the message comes via a trusted friend or family member, that doesn't make it worthy of reposting. Take a minute to think about it, use common sense, run a quick Google search if unsure, and then decide if that story is one to pass on.

Now forward this information to all your family and friends using the "share" button below!

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/facebook_status_messages_are_the_new_chain_emails.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/facebook_status_messages_are_the_new_chain_emails.php Facebook Thu, 28 Jan 2010 09:25:56 -0800 Sarah Perez
Fake Viral Videos: Is This Good Marketing? A pretty blonde woman nervously stares at the camera and begins speaking. "I'm not a stalker, I'm not crazy," she says. She then earnestly tells a story about meeting a guy in a cafe and chatting him up before he took off - leaving his jacket behind. She then apparently decided to use YouTube to help her track down her modern-day Prince Charming. A heartwarming story? Sure. Except for one problem: it was all a hoax.

]]> This wasn't a hoax put on by the blonde girl herself (real name Heidi Hardy). Although it would have been mildly interesting if she had turned out to be some attention-starved faker, that was not the case. Instead, Heidi was a model/actress hired for a campaign led by marketing group Naked Communications. The product being slyly sold was menswear - just like the jacket she claimed belonged to her mystery man.

Going by the numbers, the campaign was a success. Within four days, more than 60,000 people had watched the video. Today, the number of views is over 150,000. But did the hoax actually help the company market their product? Or did it just leave people with a bad taste in their mouth after being taken in by the hoax?

We're Always Wondering: Is it Fake?

When it comes to fake viral videos, an Australian retail company isn't  by any means the first to pull one over on us. More recently, one of the hottest viral videos out there was "Bike Hero," a daring reinterpretation of the video game "Guitar Hero," but played out on the streets using a bike instead of a guitar. The stunt was impressive and elaborate, so the video drew a lot of views. The viewing stats at the time of writing show that this video has been watched over 1.9 million times. Yet it too, was a marketing hoax.

Designed by Droga5, an ad agency, and a production company called Smuggler, "Bike Hero" was just a part of the team's marketing efforts on behalf of their client, Guitar Hero World Tour. The video's credits apparently included a CG artist, a CG supervisor, and an animation supervisor in addition to several visual effect specialists. In other words, it wasn't real.

In fact, several of the biggest viral videos aren't real: popping popcorn using your cell phone? An ad for cell phones. The office rampage? A teaser for a new movie. The Wii Fit underwear girl? Well, that one's a maybe, but the signs don't look good: the boyfriend in the video works as director of interactive media for Tinsley Advertising in Miami, Florida.

Are Hoaxes Good Marketing?

At best, hoaxes end up leaving you disappointed, at worst, angry. Are those actually the types of feelings marketers want you to associate with the products they're selling?  Although clever, fake viral videos may not be the best idea for companies.

When you find out that a video is a hoax put out by a marketing agency, are you turned off? Does your perception of the product change too? Or is half the fun trying to spot the real videos from the fakes? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.

]]> Discuss]]>
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/fake_viral_videos_is_this_good_marketing.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/fake_viral_videos_is_this_good_marketing.php Video Services Wed, 21 Jan 2009 06:32:03 -0800 Sarah Perez